View Single Post
Old 23rd-July-2007, 03:39 PM   #6 (permalink)
David Franklin
Registered User
 
David Franklin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: London
Posts: 2,866
Status: No Status
Rep Power: 6 Rep.: 2500
David Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud ofDavid Franklin has much to be proud of
Re: [ SPOILER THREAD ] Deathly hallows discussion.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jamie View Post
So what was the deal with Snape? Was he a vampire?
Animagus, possibly. Of course, JKR said explictly that wizards can't fly, but it seems she forgot to tell Voldy and Snape that.

Quote:
Major thing: What was it that Snape did to gain Dumbledore's trust? Was it just that he showed remorse and that he had a thing for Lily?
Seems so. It seems a bit stupid really, doesn't it. Although it's also implied that he doesn't have all DD's trust - something about "not telling all my secrets to someone who hangs off Voldemort's right arm". I also felt that if Snape really had gone undercover for the last 15 years solely to protect Lily's son, then I can't see him accepting DD's "the boy must die" attitude - I think you'd have seen a parting of the ways there.

Quote:
Was Nagini actually a horcrux or was Harry her replacement horcrux unbeknown to Voldemort?
Yes, Nagini was a Horcrux. Or at least Voldy thought so, and he should know! It does mean there were 7 Horcruxes and so V divided his soul into 8, not 7. The most likely explanation is Voldemort didn't realise he'd made one when he failed to AK baby Harry.

Quote:
What was the point of Grawp? He annoyed me so much, turns out he didn't have any major role to play.
Surely annoying you so much was a role all by itself?

Quote:
Who was the one who would do magic later in life under extreme circumstances?
This is the most common question I'm seeing post HP7, and I don't think anyone has an answer. JKR changed her mind, I'm guessing.
David Franklin is offline   Reply With Quote