Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Graham
Are there any other changes I've forgotten about, or any other opinions on the above?
|
From my perspective as a beginner, but trying to advance, I would have difficulty attempting to improve upon your list of basic requirements for beginner moves. However I don't see quite eye to eye with you about some of the individual moves and the verdict you give for each.
Wurlitzer: I'm very sorry to see this go as it involved a very useful anti-clockwise spin (not keen on the various pushspins) in counterpoint to the clockwise spin of the lady/Ceroc spin and, I would have thought, easier to learn and get right than the catapult (also less demanding as regards floor-craft). Problem now is, has this beginner I'm now dancing with been coming long enough to know the move? Also, in my experience, it is not going to be taught in the intermediate class and even if I'm eventually proved wrong it will only at very long intervals. Verdict: bad change.
Armjive Swizzle: this is only one variation on what I always thought of as a pretty naff move. I feel the swizzle adds a more intruiging element although it may be a little more difficult to learn. I can see its value as a building block and, since both partners can arch their backs as they come face to face, I see it as less 'uncomfortable making' than the comb (unless it is the hammerlock that was in your mind - one lady with an injury specifically asked me not to put her in this position during class). There's also the opportunity to start making statements by pausing or playing with the timing. Verdict: quite a good change.
Slo Comb: (to adopt Cerocspeak) largely agree here but to me the real change is the introduction of 'wiggles' which few beginners can do with conviction or any sort of style. I don't do this move, but if I did it would be with both hands at the lady's waist to give a better chance of those wiggles co-ordinating. If the wiggles were taught in more detail they would be a useful building block and an encouragement to improvise. Verdict: not for me.
Slo back pass: the only comment I have is that to my recollection this hasn't been taught with the arm going into the hammerlock position. With the hands in a lower position the scope for embarrassing encounters is perhaps even greater. Agree with your verdict.
Ceroc spin: can't see that this is any easier to learn or execute, but it's useful as a variation (and, boy, do I need those!). For the lady both would seem to be unambiguous leads. Verdict: a useful addition.
The new Yo-yo: one you overlooked. I approve of this as it gives more for the man to do and provides the opportunity for some self expression as well as being a swap ends move with more travel. Verdict: a positive change.
Side to side shoulders: not sure whether this is new, but it gives plenty of scope for self expression, engagement with your partner and the development of individual style, as well as introducing the travelling return.