I've been thinking along these lines for a while now. I see this as a masterclass situation where the observers get almost as much from the situation as the subjects - but without the potential embarassment!
We do something like this in our teacher's training and even then you need to be very tactful when delivering coaching and suggestions for change. I even had one of the guys sticking up for the teacher and saying I shouldn't be so critical as she was doing her best!
IMHO this critique wouldn't go down well on a normal night as it's not part of the formula. We've been considering setting up a special night with masterclasses for volunteers. But, even then, it's the potential for people to have their feelings hurt that's putting me off.
Bookmarks