Have we run out of MJ dance topics?

[Feelingpink]

I've been looking at the forum in recent weeks and have been thinking that most of the threads seem to be 'social' and 'chat' ones. There's nothing wrong in that ... but have we run out of MJ topics to discuss?

[El Salsero Gringo]

Why don't you start one?

[jivecat]

I've been looking at the forum in recent weeks and have been thinking that most of the threads seem to be 'social' and 'chat' ones. There's nothing wrong in that ... but have we run out of MJ topics to discuss?

Yes, there is nothing new to be said about the old favourites and we might as well save ourselves the bother and recycle the old threads.

However, the same old things could be said by new people who would have lots of fun saying them without realising they'd been said before.

[Feelingpink]

Yes, there is nothing new to be said about the old favourites and we might as well save ourselves the bother and recycle the old threads.

However, the same old things could be said by new people who would have lots of fun saying them without realising they'd been said before.

Except we live in the age of the Harperlink ... so, in theory, I guess we could have new threads on the old favourites, but they would be quite short as forumites link to the existing threads.

[under par]

Except we live in the age of the Harperlink ... so, in theory, I guess we could have new threads on the old favourites, but they would be quite short as forumites link to the existing threads.

I'm sure that this has been discussed before .....Mr Harper where are you?

[Gadget]

... but have we run out of MJ topics to discuss?

nope.

[David Bailey]

Except we live in the age of the Harperlink ... so, in theory, I guess we could have new threads on the old favourites, but they would be quite short as forumites link to the existing threads.

Whilst it's true that no doubt most general topics have been discussed to death, it's not exactly the End Of Dance Discussions yet, anymore than it's the end of history.

Yes, there's a wealth of past discussions available, but even with Mr Harper the search / archive mechanism is pretty poor, necessarily - that's the "living" nature of any discussion group, it always moves on.

I guess you could categorise topics as:
A/ Repeats of old topics
B/ Re-interpretations of old topics
C/ New topics

Probably we'll see lots of A/ and B/, and less of C/ as time goes on, but I doubt we'll ever run out.

[stewart38]

.. but have we run out of MJ topics to discuss?

I can think of loads of things to discuss re dance which havent before on here

e.g Do pets make good dance partners ?

[Donna]

I've been looking at the forum in recent weeks and have been thinking that most of the threads seem to be 'social' and 'chat' ones. There's nothing wrong in that ... but have we run out of MJ topics to discuss?

I think so. Someone else told me that the other day, and I have to agree it seems as though some of the topics are similar to ones discussed previously. I don't go to the dance topics so much now. The chat and fun and games ones are the best.

[Donna]

[QUOTE]e.g Do pets make good dance partners ?[QUOTE]

My dog used to be a really good spinner!! Nah really! He used to chase after his own tale and got so dizzy sometimes, he fell over.

[spindr]

Is Modern Jive a Latin Dance?
If yes, why aren't we taught to step ball-flat, like all the "proper" latin dances?
If no, why are the DJs playing so much latin music?

SpinDr

[Donna]

Is Modern Jive a Latin Dance?
If yes, why aren't we taught to step ball-flat, like all the "proper" latin dances?
If no, why are the DJs playing so much latin music?

SpinDr

Because Latin and Blues is so IN at the moment. Maybe next year it could be something different like....hip hop and swing.

[Lynn]

I think so. Someone else told me that the other day, and I have to agree it seems as though some of the topics are similar to ones discussed previously.

I've been on this forum for a couple of years, some have been on longer - topics will resurface and I think its fine to discuss them again espescially if its mainly newer people talking about them, or if people have had different experiences and possibly changed their mind on some issues. Saying 'actually we all talked about this 2 years ago when you lot weren't around' can sometimes give the message 'and we don't want to hear what you think about it' even though that isn't intended.

So I 'm happy enough to see some discussions resurface, esp when there are people on the forum who weren't part of the discussion and have interesting comments to add - though having links to previous discussions is extremely helpful, or even the new discussion continuing on the existing thread.

Or is another possibile reason why there isn't as many posts on dance related topics is that some of those topics can get heated/personal and that puts people off posting?

[Gadget]

I think that there are still roughly the same number of posts being posted about dance realted stuff as there has been in years... it's just that the number of social and non-dance posts has grown expodentially!

Normally I skip over most of the "Chit-chat" and "Fun & games" posts unless the topic catches my eye. I will always try to read any posts in the "Beginners" and "Intermediate" sections - in the hope that they will spark some understanding in me, or that I can lend some understanding to them.

[David Franklin]

I think that there are still roughly the same number of posts being posted about dance realted stuff as there has been in years... it's just that the number of social and non-dance posts has grown expodentially!

I don't think that's right. In fact, I think the dance posts have been trending down for a while now, but my perception is there's been a particularly sharp decline over the last month or two.

As Lynn says, it seems discussions of dance technique always tend to become personal; it's a particular shame how quickly everything seems to become a discussio about elitism. At the risk of offending the current regulars, I have to say a lot of my "favourite" posters have either stopped or posting, drastically cut back, or avoid posting about dance topics.

I do hope the forum doesn't go the way of rec.arts.dance, but current trends leave me pessimistic...

[ChrisA]

I do hope the forum doesn't go the way of rec.arts.dance

I don't often look there... which way has it gone?

[CJ]

I don't often look there... which way has it gone?

*Points to the left.*
That way!!!!!!!!!!!!!

FWIW, these things are cyclical. There will be more said, but for now our dancing is all perfection!!

'S ok.. I'll get my coat...

[David Franklin]

I don't often look there... which way has it gone?

For at least 3 years now, there's been little to no dance content on r.a.d. There are a few adverts for WCS dances, but the few remaining regulars seem completely unaware of a world outside the US (in fact, unaware of a world outside SoCal in most cases), or of any dances other than WCS. The 2nd gulf war pretty much killed the group off, with at least 20x as many "OT: Political" posts as anything else.

So far, so bad. What's really surprising is when you look back in google groups, and see both the number and level of posts in the past - particularly given the growth of internet usage during the same period. There's all manner of interesting discussion if you look back to, say, 1998.

The parallel is that so many of the topics back then are reminiscent of what we (used to) discuss here. Competition v.s. social dance. Ettiquete of refusal. Lead and Follow. Connection. And you used to get respected dancers (e.g. Deb Szekely) posting. Now, it's full of nothing but the equivalent of our "chat" threads, and the established dancers wouldn't be seen dead posting to it.

[stewart38]

My dog used to be a really good spinner!! Nah really! He used to chase after his own tale and got so dizzy sometimes, he fell over.

Did you think of spinning him/her the other way to restrict the feeling of dizzy ness?

Or he/she should 'spot' to avoid getting dizzy ,was he called spot ?

I think parrots have a good rocking motion

Just think of beetles jumping 100 times his/her own height ! See that in ceroc champs

See we could have a thread what animals/insects are the best at MJ

A millipede , and their foot work amazing

[under par]

Did you think of spinning him/her the other way to restrict the feeling of dizzy ness?

Or he/she should 'spot' to avoid getting dizzy ,was he called spot ?

I think parrots have a good rocking motion

Just think of beetles jumping 100 times his/her own height ! See that in ceroc champs

See we could have a thread what animals/insects are the best at MJ

A millipede , and their foot work amazing

+rep on the way for those