Originally posted by ChrisA
[ODA]
This sounds like the sort of thing Bill Gates would say.
[/ODA]
Personal benefits of the CTA ?
- TheTramp
- Senior Member
- Posts: 10672
- Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm
As far as I know, Donna (van Roose) didn't train in Australia. Most of the aeriels that I've ever seen her do (for example - though, you don't just mention aeriels in your statement), I've been on the bottom (and we would have entered the aeriels competition at Beach Boogie this year, if my college committments hadn't gotten in the wayOriginally posted by Chris
Well I wouldn't trust any ceroc teacher to teach me lift, drops or other moves that rely on specific knowledge of underlying physiology or whatever it is, but *in their role as a ceroc teacher* - some ceroc teachers know their stuff in these areas (eg Donna van Heuse springs to mind I think), but in all cases where I've seen them taught well the ceroc teachers have had outside training to learn that stuff properly - Donna trained in Australia, for instance.
If Andy and Rena suddenly became CTA certified, I'd still trust them to teach aerials (and I assume you would too David) but it's the lack of awareness of their limitations about CTA teachers that is the galling (and sometimes dangerous) thing. What they are trained to teach they generally teach brilliantly, but it's when they try to teach stuff they haven't been taught adequately or haven't picked up adequately from elsewhere. Awareness of limitations and honesty about them is a primary safeguard for good teachers (and this goes for all sorts of teachers that people put their trust in, including and up to say, University Professors!)
I've learnt a lot from Ceroc teachers but I sometimes wish they had a little more humility and awareness of their strengths and weaknesses instead of the usual all-knowing party line![]()
I'm also unaware of any ceroc teachers that do teach aeriels of any degree of difficulty. I've never seen a ceroc advertised aeriels class - although, I'm not sure that I know of any ceroc teachers (except for Rob May) who are particularly known for doing aeriels.
Although, everyone has to start somewhere with any new idea. When they first started teaching Aeriels, Andy and Rena had no experience of teaching them. They may well have had credibility as performers of them par excellance though. If ceroc were to start teaching aeriels (however unlikely this sounds - especially in Scotland
I know that this post has dealt mainly with the issue of aeriels, though it could be applied to any new area or idea that Ceroc wanted to move in (possibly with less danger involved though)
Steve
- David Franklin
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3426
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm
Agreed - the reason I picked lifts is it's clearly an area where I'd need to look outside Ceroc for tuition. It's also specialised enough an area that "good dance teaching" becomes a luxury. You go to the people who know how to do it. Many people take circus lessons or gymnastics lessons and then adapt the moves for dance.Originally posted by TheTramp
I know that this post has dealt mainly with the issue of aeriels, though it could be applied to any new area or idea that Ceroc wanted to move in (possibly with less danger involved though)![]()
In some ways a more interesting question is lead/follow or musicality. Even now, Ceroc doesn't have a shortage of teachers who could teach this at a high level. But it has shown no interest in doing so, and, I think, would find it hard to do so using it's current approach - at least so far as regular classes go.
Dave
P.S. I remember Steve's 1st ever class, when a teacher didn't turn up at Ceroc. He was fine (though of course he has got better). Just one of many who prove the CTA course isn't that essential...
-
Chris
- Senior Member
- Posts: 889
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 5:48 am
Originally posted by TheTramp
As far as I know, Donna (van Roose) didn't train in Australia. . . . Her abilities in the hip hop and aeriels department were aided by her job as a fitness instructor.
I was basing it on what she told me personally last time I saw her in the NE. At that time she was CTA approved and planning to go to Australia to complete her training to become Australian Ceroc approved. She taught a good class with mini aerials and drops and admitted privately it was based on Australian, not British, Ceroc. I might have picked her up wrong and you probably know her better than I do. The fact that she learnt the stuff in Oz before she was qualified doesn't make it less valid IMO - it was well taught which was what mattered. And as you point out she also understood it from the point of view of a fitness instructor. (Anyone got her video?)
btw there's a wee picture of her with me underneath on my website photos - nothing too fancy (we had a job getting my camera to work and conveying instructions while balanced mid-air lol)
-
bigdjiver
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4899
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
- Contact:
Originally posted by David Franklin
Agreed - the reason I picked lifts is it's clearly an area where I'd need to look outside Ceroc for tuition. It's also specialised enough an area that "good dance teaching" becomes a luxury. You go to the people who know how to do it. Many people take circus lessons or gymnastics lessons and then adapt the moves for dance.
In some ways a more interesting question is lead/follow or musicality. Even now, Ceroc doesn't have a shortage of teachers who could teach this at a high level. But it has shown no interest in doing so, and, I think, would find it hard to do so using it's current approach - at least so far as regular classes go.
[/B]
Ceroc is mainly aimed at the masses, and at the social dancer. In my view rightly so. Having done the spadework it is only now that we are beginning to see a substantial number of people who want to progress, and organisations filling that need. Ceroc may feel the need to cater for that market, or it may do better to rely on symbiosis.
- TheTramp
- Senior Member
- Posts: 10672
- Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm
I disagree with part of what you said. There's been a substantial number of people who want to progress for a long time (ever since I started dancing 4.5 years ago).Originally posted by bigdjiver
Ceroc is mainly aimed at the masses, and at the social dancer. In my view rightly so. Having done the spadework it is only now that we are beginning to see a substantial number of people who want to progress, and organisations filling that need. Ceroc may feel the need to cater for that market, or it may do better to rely on symbiosis.
The trouble has been, that there hasn't been much of an outlet for these people within the world of Modern Jive, and hence they've gone onto other forms of dance (usually Lindy or Salsa), or just given up.
Now, maybe the gap at the advanced level in the market might be catered for a little more (while still I hope keeping the same standards for those that wish to social dance), and this will maybe take the whole Modern Jive scene onto a new level. Which will be good for everyone.
Ceroc has always said that it wants to bring in younger people, as they have a longer 'dance life' (theoretically). If people are going to only do MJ for 3-5 years, before they feel that there aren't sufficient challenges available and leave for other things anyhow, then surely it matters not what age they start at....
Steve
-
DavidB
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2263
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm
One reason Ceroc has been successful is consistency. If you learn a First Move in Scotland, it is the same move that gets taught in Brighton. It is taught in the same way, in the same format of class, and within the same format of the evening. (And probably to the same music!)
I don't think this consistency applies when teaching more advanced concepts. There isn't a common 'advanced' technique. There isn't a common way of teaching advanced ideas. THere isn't even a common definition of an advanced class.
I still have to be convinced that there are enough CTA teachers who have the knowledge or experience to teach an advanced class. Explaining connection, or a latin hip action, is completely different to telling 200 people to "step back on 1". And as soon as you start saying "This is the best way to do something", you are implying that other ways aren't as good. I don't think it would look good for one CTA teacher to say one thing, and another CTA teacher to say something completely different.
You can't bring in advanced dancers from other styles (eg ballroom) and use their technique, because it doesn't always work in Modern Jive. Although there is undoubtedly huge amount we can learn from other styles, there is quite a lot that doesn't apply. You need the teachers to sort this out first before teaching a class.
The quickest way would be to get some of the existing non-CTA teachers to do the classes. But this would have its own set of problems. Even those teachers who have been doing advanced classes for years would disagree on even basic ideas.
I just don't think the dance or the teachers have developed enough yet for Ceroc to teach a common style of 'advanced' dancing. I personally think they should leave it to the independent teachers, or CTA teachers working independently, for a few more years before they lend their name to an 'advanced' form of Ceroc.
It will be interesting to see what gets taught when they start the 'Advanced' classes at Fulham next year. If it is just a harder class, then none of the above comments apply.
David
- Jon L
- Senior Member
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2003 7:54 am
Now listening some of it is personally reasonable but some of it I think is silly, and criticises dress wear and footwear.
etc.
Now I admit if the chap teaching was wearing a cardigan and slippers that might put me off, but shouldn't the teaching panel be more primarily interested in the applicants ability to get the moves across to the class?
I wonder if someone from CTA panel would post a reply on this subject ?
- stewart38
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7480
- Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am
Originally posted by RobC
As a teacher I think I am more than qualified in commenting on when the women I dance with are poor followers. I know there are a number of ladies on this forum that know me and I challenge anyone to say that I have a poor or weak lead.![]()
Reminds of a old teacher friend who once said he had just danced with 4 or 5 ladies in a row who were all poor followers
People who have been dancing 6 months can be as good as people who have been dancing 10yrs.
I dance with someone who was older then my mother yesterday and I'm nearer 40 then 30 and I guess ceroc want to encourage the 20-40 age group
-
Sonic
- Junior Member
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 13, 2003 9:48 am
Originally posted by Jon L
I hear through the grapevine about an applicants audition recommendation sheet,
Now listening some of it is personally reasonable but some of it I think is silly, and criticises dress wear and footwear.
etc.
Now I admit if the chap teaching was wearing a cardigan and slippers that might put me off, but shouldn't the teaching panel be more primarily interested in the applicants ability to get the moves across to the class?
I wonder if someone from CTA panel would post a reply on this subject ?
Rightly or wrongly, image is an important factor to any business, e.g. try turning up to an interview with a law firm in jeans/T-shirt and see whether they'll accept you even though you may have a 1st in Law from Oxford. You could argue they should be more interested in your ability as a lawyer...
Having said this, the list of things to improve or work on following an audition can run into 2 or 3 pages, of which only one sentence (maybe two) deals with your attire.