Teaching Dips & Drops technique (NZ vs rest of the world)
-
Chris
- Senior Member
- Posts: 889
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 5:48 am
Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
A short (true) story to illustrate:
At a Scottish dance night, a New Zealand woman I was dancing with (that I had just met) said to me: "Guys over here don't do an drops with me - do they think I'm not capable or something?"
I instinctively knew why no guys were doing drops with her:
She was 5'11" and fairly heavy set and large-boned. She probably weighed a bit more than me.
She was an experienced intermediate dancer. More to the point for me, she was NZ trained. I immediately flashed her a smile, "I'll do drops with you." (I quite like doing drops).
Needless to say, she did everything I threw at her correctly.
No woman should feel she has to avoid a class that contains drops because of her weight
There are very few drops in my experience that involve strength if correctly executed. There are very few drops where a follower's weight is a deciding factor if executed correctly.
The truth is, almost no Ceroc / MJ outfits in the UK bother teaching technique firmly and correctly. (I have pussyfooted around saying it is just 'different' but the truth is UK Ceroc and many MJ groups are unintentionally marginalising people - and this is just an instance. See my post here for my own attempt to explain it.)
It is no good saying 'we sort of cover that' - 'sort of' is no good. It is not an advanced technique or a style extra, it is something that should be taught as a drill so that everyone starting to learn drops knows it.
It is not difficult. It could easily be written into the Ceroc bible. (Just as the very useful and not unreleated anti-yank change suggested by DaveB "Semicircle with the hand, step back, and stop yourself!" needs to be incorporated from the first lesson - not as some high-falutin technique that people might be able to follow eventually.)
Ladies (and especially heavier ladies - and their partners), if you want to learn, I can think of a few teachers on the circuit that can be relied on to teach you this properly: (Get a private lesson or just ask them for three minutes - the basics don't take long to teach.)
Amir Giles
Nigel & Nina
James Geary (Haven't seen him teach personally but having learnt it in NZ he's not likely to have forgotten.)
Adam & Mandy (Haven't seen him teach drops but with NZ Mandy keeping an eye on him he's hardly going to teach it wrong.)
Teachers: To brush up your technique without going public, Nina Daines is also an excellent teacher-trainer. I can't imagine DavidB not being in both categories too but he's not a regular teacher (sadly for us!)
No offence to top teachers I haven't mentioned - it is not a reflection on your dance teaching, nor is it an 'advanced' technique - but you either do it or you don't - there's no 'sort of.'
In the UK there is an emphasis on fun that is great, but there are times when people need something explained in no uncertain terms, not as 'fun'. You would not teach how to wire a plug as 'fun.'
Ceroc Ltd: Angelique Meyer (NZ Ceroc Founder) is over in the UK next year. This would be an excellent time to learn, and update the standard syllabus, without losing face. And unlike the UK and Australian outfits, she has not been hampered by competition that tends to increase the 'we know best' belief (or is it just Kiwis' natural tendency to self-effacement?)
Remember - Ceroc isn't Microsoft:
Microsoft learns.
Let's hope that under Mike Ellard Ceroc will grow, instead of too often believing its own hype . . .
- David Franklin
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3426
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm
As far as your post goes - I agree that there's a lot people can do with technique to make drops safer and less strength based. But it's not for everyone, and at the end of the day, a lot of people are just going to be happier not doing drops - it's hardly all there is in dancing...
Dave
- Tiggerbabe
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5844
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Did it not occur to you that perhaps they don't like doing drops - I dance with lots of different men and not all of them do drops - and I have equally enjoyable dances with them as I do with the men who do drops. I like drops too - but they're not essential and I certainly don't look for them in every dance.Originally posted by Chris
A short (true) story to illustrate:
At a Scottish dance night, a New Zealand woman I was dancing with (that I had just met) said to me: "Guys over here don't do any drops with me - do they think I'm not capable or something?"
I instinctively knew why no guys were doing drops with her:
She was 5'11" and fairly heavy set and large-boned. She probably weighed a bit more than me.
She was an experienced intermediate dancer. More to the point for me, she was NZ trained. I immediately flashed her a smile, "I'll do drops with you." (I quite like doing drops).
The place to learn drops IMHO is in a workshop - not in a class - and of course you can still have fun whilst teaching a serious point.
-
Gary
- Senior Member
- Posts: 347
- Joined: Tue Nov 12, 2002 7:29 am
Drops technique not commonly taught?
Originally posted by Chris
...
The truth is, almost no Ceroc / MJ outfits in the UK bother teaching [drops] technique firmly and correctly.
I'm just curious to know how correct that statement is?
It seems like Chris is also saying that it should be taught, and that the teachers need more training before teaching it, and that NZ is the best place to look for the training, which are all a lot more controversial, but the statement "almost no UK outfits teach [drops] technique" statement should be an easy "true" or "false".
I'm guessing that he means "in normal classes".
I believe that most Oz teachers teach drops technique, definitely not all the time, maybe not enough, but most teachers explain technique while teaching a drop. But then maybe the technique I've been shown wasn't correct and I just don't know. Seems to work for me and my partners...
-
bigdjiver
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4899
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
- Contact:
Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Originally posted by Chris
No woman should feel she has to avoid a class that contains drops because of her weight
There are very few drops in my experience that involve strength if correctly executed. There are very few drops where a follower's weight is a deciding factor if executed correctly.
Weight and size tend to be associated. It can be very difficult to hold a large woman correctly. Weight and momentum are related. I suspect that the centre of gravity of larger ladies is higher than that of slim ones. For all these reasons large people can have problems doing certain moves at normal , or any, speed.
If any woman of any size feels uncomfortable with any move they should refuse to do it.
- Jon L
- Senior Member
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2003 7:54 am
Now to quote Lizard's Law of Drops
1) Don't trust a man
2) Don't throw yourself at a man
3) Never be afraid to say no to a man
Nothing new there
If women follow these priciples, and keep both feet on the floor and don't throw their head back which adds 30% more weight for a man, then there's no reason why larger ladies can't look impressive when doing certain types of drops and seducers.
However Chris misses on one point that I think is important
The physical size of the man
In my case (I am 5'5'' tall), a woman that tall andbroad would cause me problems on certain of the more complex drops to execute them safely
There are also certain drops which do involves lifts such as rumba drag. and also moves which involves taking the woman in between the legs such as the sausage roll .These wouldn't work with a taller and larger woman.
- JamesGeary
- Senior Member
- Posts: 287
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 10:40 am
Originally posted by David Franklin
....It seems a bit ridiculous that the only non-NZ couple he'll recommend for drops are Nigel and Nina, but he'll recommend people he hasn't seen teach just because they're NZ taught.
Originally posted by TheTramp
....By inference, from his post, Chris knows more than any (all) of them put together
No, by inference, he knows more about technique on a specialist topic than the bulk of them. And thats quite possible. In fact I'm sure its true. Writing posts about dips appears to be what he does for a living (chuckle). His posts on dip technique previously were so extensive I printed them out and used them on my workshop last weekend. And there is repetition across threads (yawn), but very few people read all the threads on the forum! Most browse randomly every couple of months.
In fact the key point is the price of real estate.
Ceroc UK bases their dancing on whatever comes out of London. Venues are ludicrously expensive in London. They need to be packed to be economic. A packed venue is not a venue you can do drops in and expect to live. I know because I used to do them non-stop in NZ and now do maybe a drop every couple of tracks.
There is a arm twisty move called a kiss-kiss which I basically never do. Thus I am not very good at it, and have never really worked at the technique. But I don't care because I never do it. So the whole concept of becoming good at it becomes a side issue.
Seperate issue now. Etiqutte for dancing with a NZ/Oz dancer > do more UCP then you normally would, do many drops and double returns because the standard way to dance with a beginner is to cut out drops and double returns and they will think your usual dancing is an attempt to insult them, dance 5-6 tracks instead of 1-2 tracks because dancing 1-2 tracks is considered a way of saying get lost.
I remember Mandy getting really put-out when she first came to the uk and danced at hammersmith because people nobody would spin her, drop her or even dance more than 3 tracks with her. Except Adam. And the rest was history.
Originally posted by JonL
<b>Now to quote Lizard's Law of Drops
1) Don't trust a man
2) Don't throw yourself at a man
3) Never be afraid to say no to a man
</B>
- TheTramp
- Senior Member
- Posts: 10672
- Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm
And don't forget that every return or turn has to be a double at least.Originally posted by JamesGeary
Seperate issue now. Etiqutte for dancing with a NZ/Oz dancer > do more UCP then you normally would, do many drops because the standard way to dance with a beginner is to cut out drops and they will be insulted by your usual dancing, dance 5-6 tracks instead of 1-2 tracks because dancing 1-2 tracks is considered a way of saying get lost. I remember Mandy getting really put-out when she first came to the uk and danced at hammersmith because people would say thanks and walk off after only 3 tracks.
Steve
-
DavidB
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2263
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
I would never offer to teach drops to anyone. I just don't do them. With the exception of the moves I've done with Lily in various routines, all the drops I've done have been unplanned. Fortunately all of them so far have become 'catches'.Originally posted by Chris
I can't imagine DavidB not being in both categories too but he's not a regular teacher
To me drops are about showing off - whether to yourself, your partner or the audience. If I want to show off, I'll do some aerials. One day I'd hope to be able to show off by dancing, but that is far harder to manage.
I generally see far too many drops done in freestyle (competitive and social) for my taste. I noticed this particularly in Australia, but I would have to say that the last freestyle before the competition is probably not the place to get an accurate idea. (On the subject of competitions, when judging freestyle, I have marked couples down for doing too many drops. One common criteria is variety of moves, and I'd expect a winning couple to be able to occasionally emphasise a highlight in the music, whilst still keeping the lady vertical.)
I would have to say that I used to see very little technique being introduced when doing a drop in a general class. Recently I've noticed an improvement, but it may just be me seeing better teachers.
Most of the people who specialise in drops (eg Lounge Lizard) seem to do dedicated workshops, and then do cover everything I'd want to hear.
I couldn't say if NZ teachers or dancers are better than anyone else. The ones I've seen are good, but not exactly revolutionary in either their approach or their knowledge. Similarly with Aussie teachers & dancers. The only difference seems to be the emphasis placed on various ideas, and the opportunity and willingness to practice.
Looks like I'd better stay over here then...Originally posted by JamesGeary
Etiqutte for dancing with a NZ/Oz dancer > do more UCP then you normally would, do many drops because the standard way to dance with a beginner is to cut out drops and they will be insulted by your usual dancing
- Jon L
- Senior Member
- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sat Jul 26, 2003 7:54 am
Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
David - just out pf interest would you be in favour of ceroc and say Britroc - outlawing totally drops and seducers or say limiting them to max of three per record in the Lucky Dip or Dance with a stranger competitions???Originally posted by DavidB
To me drops are about showing off - whether to yourself, your partner or the audience. If I want to show off, I'll do some aerials. One day I'd hope to be able to show off by dancing, but that is far harder to manage.
I generally see far too many drops done in freestyle (competitive and social) for my taste. I noticed this particularly in Australia, but I would have to say that the last freestyle before the competition is probably not the place to get an accurate idea. (On the subject of competitions, when judging freestyle, I have marked couples down for doing too many drops. One common criteria is variety of moves, and I'd expect a winning couple to be able to occasionally emphasise a highlight in the music, whilst still keeping the lady vertical.)
Looks like I'd better stay over here then...
It's interesting to learn what the judges at Britroc were after in the DWAS category, and comments that you have made are helpful for me the next time around.
- JamesGeary
- Senior Member
- Posts: 287
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 10:40 am
Re: Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Originally posted by Jon L
David - just out pf interest would you be in favour of ceroc and say Britroc - outlawing totally drops and seducers or say limiting them to max of three per record in the Lucky Dip or Dance with a stranger competitions???
I already know the answer to that (double chuckle). If it looks more like West Coast Swing by removing drops (and it does) then yes, outlaw away.
And outlawing aerials, spins and syncopation? Or instead also limit them to three each also. Or maybe you could be allowed a combined total of 3 of either spins or dips or syncopation or aerials to allocate on the fly as the music is playing. (unpleasant thought)
I don't want to have to COUNT anything of the totals of the things I'm doing while attempting to interpret music on the fly! You have enough things on your mind as it is! I can't enjoy myself dancing if I'm COUNTING things. Counting isn't dancing. Its an annoying activity that occupies a mind that should really be dancing.
-
DavidB
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2263
- Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Too many people like doing them to outlaw them.Originally posted by Jon L
David - just out pf interest would you be in favour of ceroc and say Britroc - outlawing totally drops and seducers or say limiting them to max of three per record in the Lucky Dip or Dance with a stranger competitions???
I wouldn't be in favour of a maximum, as it can have the opposite effect. People who don't like doing drops may feel they are expected to do 'x' no of drops in order to compete. This is what seems to be happening with the aerials limit in various Open categories.
My preference would be clear directions to the judges and competitors on what constitutes 'technical difficulty' and 'variety of moves' - the two categories you usually consider. Also there should be a penalty (eg marked down one or two places, or even disqualification) if any judge thought a couple was dangerous.
James would prefer every other move to be a drop - preferably without holding the lady's hands. Then it would look more like salsaOriginally posted by JamesGeary
I already know the answer to that (double chuckle). If it looks more like West Coast Swing by removing drops (and it does) then yes, outlaw away.
Good point. It is also impossible for the judges as well to keep track of what each couple has done.I don't want to have to COUNT anything of the totals of the things I'm doing while attempting to interpret music on the fly! You have enough things on your mind as it is! I can't enjoy myself dancing if I'm COUNTING things. Counting isn't dancing. Its an annoying activity that occupies a mind that should really be dancing.
But for James the real reason is different. He can't count above 2
- JamesGeary
- Senior Member
- Posts: 287
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 10:40 am
Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Originally posted by DavidB
James would prefer every other move to be a drop - preferably without holding the lady's hands. Then it would look more like salsa
Got me there. I'm still trying to learn the one where you catch her on your foot, but I've supplemented it with one where you catch her on your back.
- David Franklin
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3426
- Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Note that these moves are much easier using a different technique than Chris advocates - I don't believe there's only one true way to do drops...Originally posted by JamesGeary
![]()
![]()
Got me there. I'm still trying to learn the one where you catch her on your foot, but I've supplemented it with one where you catch her on your back.
Dave
- spindr
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1617
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:41 am
Drop the drops
1). I have a slightly dodgy back
2). If the music's slow/smooth, I find that drops break up the fluidity of the dance I'm trying to achieve. If the music's fast, then a dip/drop just gets "lost".
3). I have no guarantee that the partner I'm dancing with will hold their own weight -- there is an element of "lemming syndrome" with some partners (size has nothing to do with it
4). If the floor's crowded, I don't feel its good manners to lie my partner full-length to take up a huge amount of space, or put their head at a potentially dangerous knee/foot height.
5). Oh and lack of practice due to 1-4 above.
SpinDr.
- Gadget
- Senior Member
- Posts: 7053
- Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
- Contact:
1) Drops are completley different from Seducers and Dips; in these, the lead controlls the movement and descent and always has a physical contact/lead throught. Drops release the lady and catch her again - you need to know exactly how and where you release the lady, as well as their direction of travel, momentum and movement. And this can only be done (safely) with practice with a specific partner.
{IMHO}
2) I have been to two or three workshops on dips, drops and seducers as well as witnessing four or five taught in classes. Every time has involved serious safety notes and 'only do this with a partner you're comfortable with' subtext. Every one has stressed the importance of the lady supporting her own weight and using the man more for balance and control.
Admitedly my experience is limited and I have no comparison to the antipodean to compare against {other than Adam & Mandy's workshops} but I cannot think on any poor teaching I have seen that would invoke the poorly constructed and inflammatory title post.
I have seen a few dancers that perhaps would deserve such a scathing, but surley this is the fault of the pupill not listening, rather than the teacher not teaching.
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
- Will
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1476
- Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 11:00 am
Re: Re: Re: Re: Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Originally posted by JamesGeary
I don't want to have to COUNT anything of the totals of the things I'm doing while attempting to interpret music on the fly! You have enough things on your mind as it is! I can't enjoy myself dancing if I'm COUNTING things. Counting isn't dancing. Its an annoying activity that occupies a mind that should really be dancing.
It is a good point this....
My solution for counting ariels during competitions is to delegate the counting to Kate. If I hit the alotted maximum for a round (which I very rarely do), she tells me so. That way, if I do too many, I can blame her rather than the other way around.
It's known as "Delegating Upwards!"
- Chicklet
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2555
- Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm
apples for the teachers
Originally posted by Chris
The truth is, almost no Ceroc / MJ outfits in the UK bother teaching technique firmly and correctly.
Time for a punter's point of view.
I think I'm pretty much a run of the mill standard (out of practice) dancer, who has been very lucky to find the Forum early and takes in a lot of what is said here.
I have been to many classes and workshops, both Ceroc and independant, where dips and drops have been taught. I can think of no instance where they were taught (what's the opposite of firmly) sloppily?? and/or incorrectly, every time the emphasis on woman taking her own weight and that the man should pretty much be able to walk away at any point and don't thow yourselves girls etc etc were emphasised again and again.
as a punter some are going to say "how would she know?" well I think I've seen enough on these pages and on the floor in comps etc to know.
And so meandering to the point.....I am quite sure I have been taught well, and could do most of the moves in the workshops, those I couldn't do I watched with great interest and thought to myself, hmm must try that one again in a few months.
But put me on a dance floor 6 months later and lead me into a move that I haven't done for that long perhaps from a move that I hadn't done before ?? and I could very easily be wrong footed and off balance and make a complete arse of it....Mr Hancock and Mr Lampert et al. can more than vouch for that kind of event!!
and NOW the point, my making an arse of the dip (or any other move for that matter) will almost def. have had nothing to do with the way I was taught to do it, it was just that I often get things wrong on the dance floor.
Any possibly I'm not alone in that.
So if you dance with me and I mess up, please don't assume I'm badly taught....I'm just not very good!!!
'moan the 'chers
C
ps as we like analogies here, I have been expertly taught exactly how to decline the definite article in German, and can do it on paper in a quiet room but put me in a crowded airport, desparate for the loo and yes I'll be understood but the execution could be laughable. And surely we wouldn't blame the teacher for that??
-
Bill
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2161
- Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm
Originally posted by Bill
Given that all women should be taking their own weight when going into a dip ( unless she's being lowered into a full drop) then her weight should be the major factor for doing a dip or not
which should have had a 'not' so it reads ' then her weight should not be the major factor for doing a dip or drop'.
Must start reading my posts more carefully
-
Graham
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1981
- Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2002 1:39 pm
Since Chris seems to be having difficulty getting his point across without upsetting people I've decided to post what I think he was getting at, and he can correct me if I'm wrong. Here goes: Many larger people are marginalised by MJ (at least in the UK) because the teaching methods generally employed do not place sufficient emphasis on correct technique. With correct technique, other dancers would have no problem performing a wide variety of moves including drops with a larger partner. In NZ, greater emphasis is placed on correct technique and this enables NZ-trained dancers to perform moves such as drops with larger partners. MJ teachers in the UK should take a leaf out NZ's book and adopt a teaching style with more emphasis on correct technique.Originally posted by TheTramp
If your post wasn't about any of that, what was it about?