Does death count as an "improved situation" say, if you were very unhappy ?Gus wrote:Intersting point. If the USA kept out of it all, stooped supplying arms, diplomatic pressure and financing, do you kind think things would resolve themselves quicker?
Question, since 1945 name any and all conflicts where the involvement of the US of A has actualy improved the situation for those initially involved in the conflict?![]()
Israel v Lebanon
- Dreadful Scathe
- Senior Member
- Posts: 12530
- Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
- Contact:
Re: Israel v Lebanon
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Good question. Dunno really - but I doubt it.Gus wrote:Intersting point. If the USA kept out of it all, stooped supplying arms, diplomatic pressure and financing, do you kind think things would resolve themselves quicker?
Off the top of my head: Gulf War 1, and Kosovo, since the end of the Cold War.Gus wrote:Question, since 1945 name any and all conflicts where the involvement of the US of A has actualy improved the situation for those initially involved in the conflict?![]()
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- Gus
- Senior Member
- Posts: 5203
- Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Hmmmmm ... Gulf War may be a good one ... though the cynics could argue they didnt really finish it off, and it was a VERY one sided conflict ... except that once againt the Yanks managed to kill more of our tropps than the enemy did .... mind you, it depends who you class as the enemyDavidJames wrote:Off the top of my head: Gulf War 1, and Kosovo, since the end of the Cold War.
I thought Kosovo was a UN situation ... but it was terribly badly handled
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Kuwait got liberated, so I think they'd class it as a good result.Gus wrote:Hmmmmm ... Gulf War may be a good one ... though the cynics could argue they didnt really finish it off, and it was a VERY one sided conflict ... except that once againt the Yanks managed to kill more of our tropps than the enemy did .... mind you, it depends who you class as the enemy![]()
NATO, actually - e.g. US airpower - and the question was "Where the US got involved".Gus wrote:I thought Kosovo was a UN situation ... but it was terribly badly handled![]()
And the Kosovans got liberated, more-or-less, so I think they'd class it as a good result.
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- Baruch
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2261
- Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2004 1:54 am
Re: Israel v Lebanon
By breaking said cease-fire. As Hizbullah isn't a sovereign state like Israel, I'm sure it won't feel the pressure like Israel would when there is a call for a cease-fire. What do they care if the rest of the world disapproves of what they're doing? From their perspective, what can the rest of the world do to them that's worse than what Israel is doing anyway? Economic sanctions etc. affect sovereign states, not militias. Or rather, not only the militias.DavidJames wrote:If there's a ceasefire, how can they continue their rocket attacks?
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Ahhh, so when people call for a ceasefire, they're only talking about Israel then? I naively assumed that a ceasefire applied to both sides.Baruch wrote:By breaking said cease-fire.
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
How does an immediate ceasefire actually help? Israel will not accept the presence of Hizbullah on its Northern border, and Hizbullah will no way voluntarily disband. With or without the presence of a UN force.DavidJames wrote:Ahhh, so when people call for a ceasefire, they're only talking about Israel then? I naively assumed that a ceasefire applied to both sides.
What happens next after a ceasefire then?
- WittyBird
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6889
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2005 11:08 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
They all go for a cup of tea to discuss in great detail the pedants on the Ceroc Scotland forumEl Salsero Gringo wrote:
What happens next after a ceasefire then?
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
I think you mean pendants.WittyBird wrote:They all go for a cup of tea to discuss in great detail the pedants on the Ceroc Scotland forum![]()
- WittyBird
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6889
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2005 11:08 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Well anykind of Jewellery reallyEl Salsero Gringo wrote:I think you mean pendants.
- Baruch
- Senior Member
- Posts: 2261
- Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2004 1:54 am
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Of course it applies to both sides. However, agreeing to a cease-fire is one thing]observing[/I] it is another, and a sovereign state is more likely to accept international pressure to do so than an armed militia/terrorist group*.DavidJames wrote:Ahhh, so when people call for a ceasefire, they're only talking about Israel then? I naively assumed that a ceasefire applied to both sides.
*Delete as appropriate.
- David Bailey
- Senior Member
- Posts: 17001
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Well, people immediately stop dying, for a start, which seems to me to be a Good Thing.El Salsero Gringo wrote:How does an immediate ceasefire actually help?
Why not? It has done for the past 20-odd years after all.El Salsero Gringo wrote:Israel will not accept the presence of Hizbullah on its Northern border,
This is probably true, at least in the forseeable future.El Salsero Gringo wrote:and Hizbullah will no way voluntarily disband. With or without the presence of a UN force.
A ceasefire is only a starting-point for a process, of course. But it seems like a good one.El Salsero Gringo wrote:What happens next after a ceasefire then?
In the long run, Israel can, for example, offer Syria (who seem slightly less nutty than Iran, on the Loony Regime Scale) the Golan Heights in exchange for the disbanding of Hizbullah, declaration of peace from Syria, and other shows of goodwill.
I can't see Iran being involved in any negotiations, however - I doubt Israel has much to offer them.
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
OK, let's say that Israel is no longer prepared to accept the presence of Hizbullah on its northern border.DavidJames wrote:Why not? It has done for the past 20-odd years after all.
I'm afraid I don't see any such process actually happening. There's been no progress on one in the last twenty years, and it's only the current military action that seems to have galvanised anyone to think about one for the future.DavidJames wrote: ceasefire is only a starting-point for a process, of course. But it seems like a good one.
I suppose the view from Israel is that the Golan has always been on offer in return for a true peace. Just like the Sinai was returned to Egypt. However seeing as the war of '67 in which the Golan was captured was started by Syria (on the northern frontier) it really ought to be up to Syria to start the process. It was a war that they lost - rather soundly - after all. Nothing the Syrians have ever done since 1967 have shown the slightest inclination to any kind of acceptance of Israel (unlike Sadat and Egypt in 1979). If I were Israeli, I'd probably find it rather hard to swallow that the world expects me to put my northern border at risk just to see if the Syrians will come to the table. A decisive military victory over your enemy in a war you didn't start should earn you some political advantage when it comes to negotiating a peace, shouldn't it?DavidJames wrote:In the long run, Israel can, for example, offer Syria (who seem slightly less nutty than Iran, on the Loony Regime Scale) the Golan Heights in exchange for the disbanding of Hizbullah, declaration of peace from Syria, and other shows of goodwill.
By the way, I've been to the Golan. You don't have to be a military tactician of genius proportion to realise that the same stunning views of the plains of northern Israel would give a belligerent enemy a decisive strategic advantage. Unlike the Sinai, which is hundreds of miles of desert. So you might expect the Israeli public to be a little more cautious about taking a risk on Syria.
It seems rather a pity that Israel has to 'offer' something to Iran. I'm not quite sure what Israel has ever done to the Iranians to offend them, except perhaps to exist at all.DavidJames wrote:I can't see Iran being involved in any negotiations, however - I doubt Israel has much to offer them.
- WittyBird
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6889
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2005 11:08 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
-
Barry Shnikov
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6709
- Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Sounds unlikely - Dresden was the best known but not by any means the only such raid in the waning days of that war.bigdjiver wrote:O.T. I worked with an M.A. in math who claimed that he had worked on the mathematics of fire-storms during the war. He claimed that Dresden had been selected as a target because it was a historic town, with lots of narrow streets and wooden structure in the buildings. It was as close as they could get in Europe to a typical Japanese town. One reason Dresden was selected was to confirm their math and to practise fire-bombing such cities as a prelude to the bombing of Japan and the later use of nuclear weapons.
That's the missing element, by the way; the war was essentially won by the time Dresden was bombed; yes it probably made some difference to the German's ability to allocate resources to 'military defence', but hardly one proportionate to the death, destruction and agony inflicted.
-
Barry Shnikov
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6709
- Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Really? Admittedly it is unlikely we would see this in the short-term. But to believe that there will always be such people about would be seriously alarming.El Salsero Gringo wrote:I agree with that sentiment, but I don't think that there would be *no* people willing to blow up buses of schoolchildren, no matter how saintly Israel was.
The point is, there has got to be one party that is prepared to break the chain.
Oh wow.
I've just realised that I may be guilty of a sort of racism - I'm wondering if there isn't something in the deep reaches of my brain that thinks that Israel has more responsibility to 'break the chain' because part of me views Muslims as 'less civilised'.
I shall have to think hard about whether that is true...
-
Barry Shnikov
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6709
- Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Sorry; using 'disenfrachised' in the looser sense rather than 'being deprived of a vote'.El Salsero Gringo wrote:{snip}don't think that the creation of Israel as a state disenfranchised anyone{snip}
-
Barry Shnikov
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6709
- Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
...well, it is a bit, even if not capable of sustaining a chain reaction...El Salsero Gringo wrote:Depleted uranium is not radioactive,
...again, it is a bit...not especially toxic
-
Barry Shnikov
- Senior Member
- Posts: 6709
- Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
You don't have 'peace' with terrorists.David Franklin wrote:If we have peace with the terrorists, then the terrorists have won.
This is one of Bush's biggest achievements - we all talk of a 'war on terror' and I'm convinced that 99% of people haven't thought about what calling the endeavour to prevent terrorism entails.
What are a terrorist's 'war aims'? Won't there be as many different versions as there are terrorists? How do you wage war on unknown opponents? Who do you negotiate with - and how can they guarantee the compliance of their fellow terrorists? How do you defeat a terrorist group?
Few labels in history have been more misleading nor more successful.
- El Salsero Gringo
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4881
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm
Re: Israel v Lebanon
Barry Shnikov wrote:Sorry]In what looser sense of disenfranchised are you using the word then?