Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips... You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
Originally posted by Gus Why is sum total of musical interpretation seemingly restricted to talking about breaks. Breaks are NOT musical interpretation ... as said before they are simply "Simon says Stop" Watch a dance floor and watch every Herbert freeze in their tracks ... WHERE THE H*LL IS THE INTERPRETATION???.
Originally posted by Gus Ahem .... didnt realise I'd hit such a nerve:sorry
I don't think it was so much about hitting a nerve, more the case that as Mary said breaks are a simple step one example, and as Tramp mentioned 75% (more in Australia) still have not taken that first step.
I did quote "breaks" as a simple example only, I did not intend to give the impression that there was no more to music and dance than that.
If you read from post 3 (Gadget) and post 4 (Mary) onwards I think you will find much more mentioned on this thread.
Originally posted by Martin I don't think it was so much about hitting a nerve, more the case that as Mary said breaks are a simple step one example, and as Tramp mentioned 75% (more in Australia) still have not taken that first step.
Fair point. Maybe its a bit of na sore point with myself that drops became the defining method in musical interpretation fo a while ... much the same as it seemed to be (or still is) for all tracks to finish with a deep drop.
I heatily concur that you have to start somewhere ... and maybe using breaks really suits some peoples style ... I was just (slightly tongue in cheek) pointing out there is more.
Dweling on the subject, another facet is that musical imterpretation can only come to the fore if the DJ is playing music that begs to be interpreted. No doubt LL and Tramp can make comment on that
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
Originally posted by Gus Ahem .... didnt realise I'd hit such a nerve:sorry
No probs - back down from orbit now
And Chris ... please read what I said more carefully ...
Sorry, what part of:
Breaks are NOT musical interpretation
... didn't I understand?
The point I was making, and for once I thought I was fairly clear ... was that breaks are not the ONLY type of interpreatation ... though that is the way they can be discussed ... in the real world as well as in the Forum. I disagree that breaks are the ONLY was to start ... I've seen many dancers start by using more expressive hands and changing the moves to suit the beat. Of course, I totaly agree with starting in stages..... I never said that anyone jumps straight into advanecd.
I wouldn't disagree with this.
But if you read my post more carefully , you would have noticed that I wasn't referring just to breaks.
I also mentioned percussion, instruments, phrases... which, of course, aren't the whole story either.
I just felt that your "watch every Herbert freeze in their tracks" on a thread where there are some genuine enquiries from people that obviously want to advance their dancing was unhelpful, in the sense that it came over, to me at least, as very disparaging.
It doesn't bother me now so much, but a while back when I had only the barest inkling that I might be able to learn to dance musically, it definitely would have done. Like I said, I'm a million miles from expert, but at least dancing is fun again and I feel like I'm learning.
I think we should think twice before telling people that what they're doing is invalid.
Originally posted by Gus Dweling on the subject, another facet is that musical imterpretation can only come to the fore if the DJ is playing music that begs to be interpreted. No doubt LL and Tramp can make comment on that
What? Me make a comment? Don't be silly!!
Okie. My 2p worth though. All tracks can be interpreted. Of course, it's easier, if you've got a track that has lots of possible interpretation. It's almost impossible not to put some form of interpretation into 'All that Jazz' for example.
It's tracks that don't have so many obvious places for interpretation that are more challenging I think. Although, they may so little opportunity as to be pretty boring (searching for the odd bit of interpretation in an otherwise monotonous track may be challenging, but may also not be much fun!!).
Although, I have to admit that I prefer tracks that have much more 'attitude' than tracks that just go 'boom, boom, boom'.
Interpretation to me comes from feeling the music and becoming one with it. Feeling the beat is part of that, but I try to let the music play me as if I was an instrument. Don't dance to the music, dance the music! You will have to be fully in your body for this, not just your head.
Certain moves work well for certain phrases. You'll develop your own interpretation and repertoire, but here's some examples of what I have used:
Octopus, pretzel, one handed catapult, and changing places combined with manspin - great for swirling phrases that repeat back and forth (listen out for the call and response guitar strums in superman lovers starlight, also the swirling synth pads in Paul van Dyks nothing but you)
Armjive, side to side - great for funky bass lines (eg db boulevard's point of view, superman lovers starlight, MJ's Billie Jean, room 5/oliver cheatham's make luv), and classic rock and roll (try it to van morrisons brown eyed girl)
Yoyo - great for when a dramatic bassline, drumbeat or other development comes in and you want to pick up on it (listen for the one at 1:19 in No doubts my life)
slo haleluila, manspin into catapult hold - great for those indescribable parts of a song where theres a fill with a dramatic increase/decrease in pitch and velocity (a good example is found in no doubts my life from 2:20 to 2:40)
Hatchback and wurlitzer - suddenly the music increases in velocity, great to lead into a wide range of moves that create greater distance, movement, and energy. It's the forceful push or flick out combined with a spin and some distance that does it.
seducers, drops, twirls, wurlitzer wrap in - great for dramatic finishes to the song
basket, basket walk, sway,sway walk, first move, haleluila, wraps - great to emphasise romantic lyrics
slo combs, slo halelulias, latin walks, penguins, arm slides, frisks, hip rolls, grinds, man spoons and lady spoons - great to emphasise sexy and intimate parts of a song esp those bluesy saxophones!
Basket walks, sway walks, trains - great for slow rolling basslines esp with accents (eg Lisa Ekdahl's Vem Vet at 00:48)
Changing places, first move colombian, Latin walks, first move tango variations, hip rolls - Latin rhythms
Freezing - theres a break as suddenly the music stops - if you don't know it's coming, you have to be sharp. The other day I was doing a man spoon into a shoulder drop and as the music stopped I placed the hands on my shoulders with emphasis and just froze - it was very dramatic and my lady laughed!
Certain moves will produce distance very quickly eg wurlitzer, catapult, side to side shoulders and so are great for when songs pick up in energy. Likewise baskets, sways, accordians, first moves, armjives, combs, octospins etc keep the distance close and are good for quiet subdued sections.
Develop your own flourishes and footwork in response to the song. What are you doing with your spare hand and arm? Could it be reflecting something going on in the song? What about your facial expressions? This skill is soon picked up by going to a nightclub and dancing solo! Also try watching some tango and salsa dancers, there's lots of flourishes and dramatic footwork and body movements. You don't have to learn a new dance style, just see what's possible.
Originally posted by starlightdancer
Certain moves work well for certain phrases. You'll develop your own interpretation and repertoire, but here's some examples of what I have used:....
Starlighter ... superb posting .... must have taken you ages to put all that down More than a few points there that I think most dancers could benefit from .... intend to print off and try and work through some of your suggestions. Many thanks.
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
Originally posted by Gus Starlighter ... superb posting .... must have taken you ages to put all that down More than a few points there that I think most dancers could benefit from .... intend to print off and try and work through some of your suggestions. Many thanks.
I had to go offline to write it!
I think the fact that I compose music helps me to listen and interpret what's going on.
I agree with the point that "freezing on breaks" is one of the most common and 'easiest' forms of musical interpritation - and I will always use a freeze on a break if it fits in with the music and the move preceeding it.
I think that if you can stop any move at any point during it, {especially if it's in time with the music } then you are well on the way to being an advanced dancer and having the tools that allow better exploration of "musical interpritation"
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
Originally posted by Gadget I think that if you can stop any move at any point during it, {especially if it's in time with the music } then you are well on the way to being an advanced dancer and having the tools that allow better exploration of "musical interpritation"
I hear what you say but my personal view is that hitting breaks doesn't have that much to do with becoming an advanced dancer .... I think that is an altogether more complex proposition. Thinking of the likes of Viktor, Dan Baines, Roger Chin .... I dont think any of them are noted for breaks.
I agree with the consensus view that breaks are probably the easiest way into musical interpretation ... but its a BIG step from there to being advanced. Mind you .. if anyone can actualy define what an advanced dancer looks like in under 30,000 word ....
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
Mind you .. if anyone can actualy define what an advanced dancer looks like in under 30,000 word .... [/B]
I hope this wasn't rhetorical...if so please forgive me I'm new
Firstly, I would like to throw out another question: is there a difference between an advanced dancer and an advanced Modern Jiver? Maybe better in a new thread............??
As for the definition of an advanced dancer from a self-confessed intermediate dancer whose partner is clearly an advanced dancer, some of the things that set her apart, other than decades of dance experience & current regular professional work, include…..the ability to make stepping forwards and backwards look like a smooth effortless continuous glide, (it doesn’t actually look like stepping, ….more like skating),....easily gets away with spontaneous individual interpretation within the MJ move, tightness & precision while being relaxed enough to have fun, the ability to be complimentary and compatible with your partner (even if having to dance down) flexible enough to adapt to all levels of partners & still look good, the ability to follow spontaneous inventive moves while freestyling, the ability to not only to spin technically well and explosively, but also to stop on a dime and not miss a beat, hence dynamic but controlled, consistent aesthetically pleasing body position, the ability to instinctively work the lyrics in-between beats and instruments in harmonious ways, to make really difficult things look natural & much easier than they are, and finally an instinctive awareness and control of body weight, and probably another 29000 ways to describe it!!
I like watching dancers who look like they music is being played by their bodies, call them advanced or just bloody good or whatever...they inspire....
Posting, unbeknown to my partner….shhhhhhhh..she will get a big head...
P.S. please go on about breaks this is very interesting and helpful
Originally posted by Martin I don't think it was so much about hitting a nerve, more the case that as Mary said breaks are a simple step one example, and as Tramp mentioned 75% (more in Australia) still have not taken that first step.
I did quote "breaks" as a simple example only, I did not intend to give the impression that there was no more to music and dance than that.
I found it interesting that Viktor, when he won in Australia last year seemed to dance through the things I think are breaks.......although he is clearly an awesome dancer....whats that about?
Originally posted by Dotse I found it interesting that Viktor, when he won in Australia last year seemed to dance through the things I think are breaks.......although he is clearly an awesome dancer....whats that about?
Viktor's dancing is indeed awesome - his ability to connect complicated moves together seamlessly and fluidly at almost any speed, and make them look easy, is unmatched by any that I've seen. He can do this with inexperienced dancers too, so his lead must also be damn good.
Similarly, I have seen no one to equal his natural grace, which turns everything he dances into pure artistry.
Personally, though, and this is no more than an opinion, I find Nigel and Amir, who seem (to my relatively untutored eye), to do a lot more with the music, more interesting to watch.
Originally posted by Dotse As for the definition of an advanced dancer . . .
Great description Dotse, now I'm looking forward to this evening even more, as I know I'll be dancing with several who fit all this!
One bit that I'd like to add (though I've said this before on another thread), is the ability (for followers) to take the lead at appropriate opportunities (I'm not talking about leading "moves" as such), and with the right partner the leader is able to pick up on this and mirror or complement it.
Maybe Viktor's style comes more through Salsa, is interpreting the music rarer there? (I don't know much about Salsa, as I couldn't listen to a whole evening of Salsa music!)
Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
Originally posted by Sheepman Maybe Viktor's style comes more through Salsa, is interpreting the music rarer there? (I don't know much about Salsa, as I couldn't listen to a whole evening of Salsa music!)
At one point last year I asked my salsa teacher if she would perhaps might kindly etc take five minutes each week to run thru the previous week's routine.
I (and the class) got an instant mini-lecture (quite rightly IMO) about it not being about moves but about principles, and if we learnt those properly we wouldn't need to learn moves because we'd just make our own moves up all the time.
This to me is the perfect attitude (certainly one I try to emulate), choosing moves only to illustrate the principles being taught. It naturally leads to more interpretative dancing than reciting of moves.
I know 'move-collectors' will disagree however, and within a ceroc-context would see no harm in a recap at beginners stage.
Not all salsa teachers are so aware though.
As to the music, it is infectious when you start dancing to it (probably to do with the intricacies of the rhythms) - I've gone to much more trouble tracking down an individual salsa song than I ever did for a jive song (And I'm still not that far past the beginner stage at salsa!)
Originally posted by Sheepman Great description Dotse, now I'm looking forward to this One bit that I'd like to add (though I've said this before on another thread), is the ability (for followers) to take the lead at appropriate opportunities (I'm not talking about leading "moves" as such), and with the right partner the leader is able to pick up on this and mirror or complement it.
Greg
Thanks for the positive words.....Yep I agree...I think that really good followers need room to improvise/lead........let them show it off ....I have always wanted more input form my much better half....still working on how to keep the 'partnering going'............and prevent me from looking even more like a rock due to the contrast effect!!!!
Personally, though, and this is no more than an opinion, I find Nigel and Amir, who seem (to my relatively untutored eye), to do a lot more with the music, more interesting to watch.
Chris [/B]
Sorry haven't seen these guys, but I would be very interested in getting hold of a video/s...any ideas?
Also, I didn't learn about breaks in about 2.5 years of dancing......I am still trying to work out what this newly found term actually means from this awesome source of info "the discussion board".......so maybe I am not in the best position to judge other's interpretation of breaks......but I guess one break is a clear slowing down of the tempo......or loss of the heavy beat?????
Martin saw Viktor dance and said he won it on interpretation so maybe he could fill me in on how he dealt with breaks...or in my words slow dead bits?
I will go back and check for definitions of a break....any help would be greatly appreciated..
Originally posted by Dotse Martin saw Viktor dance and said he won it on interpretation so maybe he could fill me in on how he dealt with breaks...or in my words slow dead bits?
I certainly didn't mean to imply Viktor's dancing was unmusical or non-interpretive in any way - his choice of moves to fit the music is lovely, and I wouldn't feel qualified to criticise it in any way.
Even as I was saying that I find Nigel and Amir more interesting to watch, I was conscious of the likelihood that I'm just not seeing a lot of the subtlety of what Viktor does because of my own inexperience.
I probably need to watch more... but that would mean dancing less
Originally posted by Dotse
As for the definition of an advanced dancer from a self-confessed intermediate dancer whose partner is clearly an advanced dancer, some of the things that set her apart, other than decades of dance experience & current regular professional work, include…..the ability to make stepping forwards and backwards look like a smooth effortless continuous glide, (it doesn’t actually look like stepping, ….more like skating),....easily gets away with spontaneous individual interpretation within the MJ move, tightness & precision while being relaxed enough to have fun
These are useful comments and I would like to hear more about what constitutes a really good female dance partner and, from those awesome ones, how they got there? I am talking about people like your partner by the sound of it, LilyB, Kate and Nina (IMHO). I have ideas about how to improve but could do with help in honing my map now that I have begun to see the beauty of more musical following!
the ability to be complimentary and compatible with your partner (even if having to dance down) flexible enough to adapt to all levels of partners & still look good
In my experience disparity in growth of dancing skills between partners can lead to a lot of conflict in a relationship. Isn't it great that your lovely partner is willing and able to help you "catch up" in your understanding!
please go on about breaks this is very interesting and helpful
Ditto
Tell me what is it you plan to do
with your one wild and precious life? (Mary Oliver, House of Light)
Originally posted by Sylph These are useful comments and I would like to hear more about what constitutes a really good female dance partner and, from those awesome ones, how they got there?
There are two ways to get there (IMHO).
1. Dance with lots of good men who can lead you well
2. Watch those people that you admire, and try to emulate what they do. (This doesn't mean that you have to go for the Andy 'I want to be Lily' approach. Take certain things (the best bits) from all the people that you want to be like).
Classes and workshops only help up to a point in this area I think (even classes designed for musical interpretation). Although, obviously they are good for getting new moves from (and while the dance should be all about the music and the movement to it, having moves that you can put in doesn't hurt, there's nothing wrong with being a 'move accumulator' - provided you use them well, and in the right way).