Page 4 of 5
Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2003 1:58 pm
by Paul F
Originally posted by ChrisA
Well, this is why I was interested in David’s view of Amir’s class. As I said before, I find it far harder than either Nigel's or indeed Viktor's most difficult ones.
But it's a big mistake to imagine that the difficulty in Amir's classes has got anything to do with the moves he teaches. To get the fluidity and grace you see when he demos what he teaches with Kate, demands balance, coordination, musicality and leading ability that is far beyond mine at the moment. So I come away feeling about one inch high, nerves shredded.
But nevertheless, a tiny bit better and totally inspired.
Chris
Definately agree. its not easy by any stretch of the imagination.
What i meant was if people struggle with the 'inter/adv' classes on a tue and wed and people struggle with the style classes (including me

) then it is completely impossible to expect success in any advanced lessons without such things as gradings.
I must re-iterate though i dont like the gradings idea but cant see any other way

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2003 1:59 pm
by Pammy
Originally posted by Paul F
and people struggle with the style classes (including me
)
Honey, style is one thing you're not lacking in!

Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2003 5:43 pm
by Gus
Originally posted by Paul F
I must re-iterate though i dont like the gradings idea but cant see any other way
So ... back to reality ... how would you integrate advanced lessons into a normal club night. Although there rae many different views about what should be included ... one factor that consistently crops up is that the class will be beyond the capabiltity of most of the attending dancers .... so how do you tell them to s*dd off and stay off the floor until they are allowed back on again
As I've mentioned before ... face your usual class of 100 intermediates with an advanced class and stress that only the very experienced should attempt it ... and guess how many dancers drop out.
Self-certification
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 1:29 am
by spindr
Originally posted by Gus As I've mentioned before ... face your usual class of 100 intermediates with an advanced class and stress that only the very experienced should attempt it ... and guess how many dancers drop out.
Well, it depends what else is on offer -- an (advanced) class versus no class -- you will only get one answer from dancers. If you let people choose between an advanced class and an improver/intermediate one -- and you may get more people switching. If you show people the "advanced routine" (or more likely list concepts to be discussed) versus "improver/intermediate" one -- and people will make a more informed choice (yes I have definitely seen this happen).
Call the advanced class a "style-orientated class" and maybe people who think they don't need styling tips won't feel like attending (even if they know that they are advanced

). Call the improvers/intermediate class a "moves-orientated class" and maybe people won't feel that they are demeaning themselves by attending.
Neil.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 1:44 am
by DavidB
A ferw years ago we organised some workshops by a top US West Coast Swing teacher. At the time there were probably only about 20 people who did WCS more than twice a year in the UK.
The beginners classes had about 30. The intermediate had about 40, and the advanced over 70.
They weren't advanced classes by any definition - we just knew that if people could only do one workshop, they would pick the one called 'advanced'.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 4:10 am
by JamesGeary
Originally posted by DavidB
So I would say the difference between an intermediate dancer and an advanced dancer is knowledge.
I'm not so sure about that. I got a book on ballroom dancing and read it. Then I put the book down. Then I looked again at the book and decided that I hadn't improved my dancing at all.
Then I picked it up and looked at the pictures. Copied a few poses. I think that might have improved my ability a little bit. If I had an actual moving video I could have done more. My body reflexes and habits could be improved, but I don't know how much knowledge I would accumulate.
Advanced ability = knowledge, sounds perilously close to learning via scripts. I think genuine improvement has to come mostly from mimicry of observed subtleties + occasional chance discoveries.
Re: Videoing??
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 11:50 am
by Rachel
Originally posted by DavidY
I'd love to have an expert tell me what I'm doing wrong.
How about a workshop which starts by videoing your dancing and then telling you what you're doing wrong? Have been to training like this before in a non-dance environment - it's very uncomfortable but can also be very effective.
I'm really late to pick up on this! But me too - I've love to be told (nicely!) what I'm not doing right, or what I could particularly improve on.
But I guess that's why you'd have private lessons, if you could afford it.
Hey David - in the absense of any such workshops as yet, how about you and me have our own little buddy system where we can dance and then give each other constructive criticism. What do you think?
Rachel
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 2:07 pm
by Gadget
Originally posted by JamesGeary
Advanced ability = knowledge, sounds perilously close to learning via scripts. I think genuine improvement has to come mostly from mimicry of observed subtleties + occasional chance discoveries.
While I understand that mimicry is necissary to "get" various moves and 'flair', I think that learning {completley} by mimicry is worse than learning by scripts: This just results in a carbon copy of the mimic-ed artist.
At least by learning through 'knowledge' sources you have a chance to put your own interpritation on the information and can argue there is no
correct way to do something. (ie you have no definitive source to compare against.)
Gus asked how to incorporate "Advanced" lessons into a normal class:
Would it not be possable to scatter the advanced knowledge allong side the intermediate areas in the form of {eg}"As an alternative to just stepping
here, try and hit the beat with your foot and follow the body through..." etceteras.
The tricky bit would be knowing where the balance lay between alienating the majority of 'intermediate' dancers and educating the rest of the 'advanced' dancers.
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 5:08 pm
by Paul F
As for how and when to incorporate advanced classes I would have to say that they need to be seperate from the 'normal' classes. The obvious and possibly the hardest way of doing this would be to have seperate 'advanced' lessons possibly on different days.
This is, of course, very hard as the venue may not be available etc. but at least this draws the first dividing line giving those thinking about moving up a moment of pause.
Looking back at one of James' posts I think he mentioned something really interesting bout NZ i think. He mentioned that because there is grading (or u ask the teacher) people make sure they are good enough to go up to advanced level. They need that milestone to consider otherwise they will just turn up 'as usual'.
To run a seperate night for adv classes may get them to think again.
As an example I have to think back to the advanced classes Mick Wenger taught in Finchley on a monday night. The monday night had changed from a normal night to an advanced night.
As a result the SAME people turned up regardless. Adam made it clear in on the web and Mick made it clear in the class that it was that much harder. Unfortunately everyone turned up anyway. I can realistically say that ~70% of the class simply couldnt get it.
Mick is obviously one of the best teachers so it certainly wasn't him.
I know the advanced nights have stopped now. I can only imagine it is for this reason. I know quite a few experienced dancers who went down and said the same. Coupling this with the fact that there were some very annoying people there (hecklers

) it must have suffered.
A seperate night for an advanced class. Is that the only way?
Posted: Wed Dec 10, 2003 5:26 pm
by TheTramp
Originally posted by Paul F
A seperate night for an advanced class. Is that the only way?
Possibly. Although, I'll be interested to hear how the new class (in the other room) at Fulham is going. Can't remember whether the advanced class was going to run at the same time as the intermediate. Or the beginners. Or just after both when the freestyle was on. Or what
But having all 3 on the same night might solve some of the possible problems.... I think it's a nice concept however....
Steve
Re: Self-certification
Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:47 am
by RobC
Originally posted by spindr
Well, it depends what else is on offer -- an (advanced) class versus no class -- you will only get one answer from dancers. If you let people choose between an advanced class and an improver/intermediate one -- and you may get more people switching. If you show people the "advanced routine" (or more likely list concepts to be discussed) versus "improver/intermediate" one -- and people will make a more informed choice (yes I have definitely seen this happen).
Since we started an improvers class in Fleet (really a low intermediate level - but what's in a name) running at the same time as the usual intermediate (really a challenging intermediate/advanced level), we have seen a lot of people choosing to do the improvers class over the intermediate class, especially on the monthy N&N advanced class nights - It has got to the point now that on some nights I even have more people in my improvers class than in the main venue doing the intermediate class.
It has definitely been my experience that if you give people the choice, they will choose the class that they feel most comfortable with, which means that you can push the higher class harder safe in the knowledge that if people are struggling to keep up, they can drop down to the lower class and still enjoy the evening. Don't give them the choice and of course they will still try and join in with the harder class - who can blame them - they have paid their money to get in for the evening and want to learn something, not sit around for 40 mins waiting for freestyle to start !
If the arrangement that Simon and Mike are coming to (and as far as I'm aware, the contract is yet to be signed) is an indication of the way Mike is planning to take Ceroc, we have some very interesting times ahead. Simon is still going to be teaching Lindy - as part of a Ceroc evening - and has infact announced tonight that as of January, will be starting a second lindy class on thursdays in Fleet. We will still be continuing the Jive Bug Fleet arrangement of once a month replacing the usual intermediate class with an advanced class - for the next 2 months, we have Mick stepping up to fill N&N's shoes.
So, as they say, watch this space.
Rob
Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 9:31 am
by David Franklin
One of the big things in Australia seems to be teaching team routines over several weeks. There are different levels of routine, with the advanced ones having lots of fast complicated moves and often big aerials.
It occurs to me this has a lot of advantages:
(1) Sidesteps the "elitism" thing, at least to some extent - it's very much parallel to the normal classes rather than "above them".
(2) The participants are making a real commitment (including paying for the whole course up front, if I understand correctly). You're also probably letting other people down if you drop out. This helps with motivation when you're at the "I'm just can't do this" stage...
(3) One thing I find a lot with new (and therefore initially difficult) moves is that they tend not to get practiced. When you're in freestyle, and the music is twice as fast as when you learnt the move, and you need to worry about floorcraft etc., putting in a move you're unsure of is really hard. Much easier to practice it when you know the music, know where the move is supposed to fit in the music etc...
(4) Hopefully you learn about performance, things like facing the audience, carriage, smiling etc...
(5) You have an end goal and get a chance to show it all off!
The disadvantages I see:
(1) Doesn't cover a lot of areas people want to learn. (e.g. lead/follow, on the fly interpretation ...)
(2) Really hard to make work without fixed partners. Otherwise everyone gets affected when someone isn't up to scratch or just can't make a class.
(3) Need someone to choreograph the routines. I think it would take a while to "ramp up" to the number of routines taught in Australia. (but Ceroc UK could "buy" the Oz routines...)
(4) Judging by reactions on this forum, 12 teams cabarets at Ceroc championships would not go down very well...
Dave
Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 2:25 pm
by cerocmetro
Originally posted by David Franklin
One of the big things in Australia seems to be teaching team routines over several weeks. There are different levels of routine, with the advanced ones having lots of fast complicated moves and often big aerials.Dave
Is it me or is CerocMetro invisible??
We have been teaching choreographed routines for 4 years now. We have different levels, from beginners to advanced routines. We have only ever done one advanced one and we won the Ceroc Champs with it in 2001.
The routines have been a fantastic way for individuals to look great. Not become great dancers, but look like great dancers. The first thing we do is stress that they need to lose their style. For a routine to work in a group, everyone has to look the same. Interestingly enough, when we decided to enter the Champs we auditioned. We found that all the so called top dancers were no good becuase their styles were too strong and they were not prepared to put in the work and be told how to dance.
Individuals look great because they are doing music interpretation to the extreme but not having to understand it. We have a regular crowd who do every routine we produce, they have all become much better dancers and have learnt some wonderful and some very scary moves. In reality these have been advanced classes.
We taught a beginners one in Perth over the summer. It went down well I believe. The main feedback was how good it felt dancing to a whole track feeling right all the way through and what fun it was.
Gordon taught one of our routines at Camber recently. From what I understand the reception was amazing.
Apart from the advanced routines, partners can swap, where there are big moves or lifts, we try to make alternatives that fit in.
You might not become a great dancer overnight, but this is a way to get an idea of what it feels like to be one.
To get details of our next routine, send an email to
ceroc@hotmail.com
Adam
Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 2:41 pm
by David Franklin
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Is it me or is CerocMetro invisible??
We have been teaching choreographed routines for 4 years now. We have different levels, from beginners to advanced routines. We have only ever done one advanced one and we won the Ceroc Champs with it in 2001.
Sorry Adam

On t'other hand, had a quick look at your website, and I can't say I could see anything about this there.
Individuals look great because they are doing music interpretation to the extreme but not having to understand it. We have a regular crowd who do every routine we produce, they have all become much better dancers and have learnt some wonderful and some very scary moves. In reality these have been advanced classes.
So did this work better than your "official" advanced classes? I would think you'd get a better selection of dancers without having to bruise egos too badly.
Dave
Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 2:47 pm
by cerocmetro
Originally posted by David Franklin
Sorry Adam
On t'other hand, had a quick look at your website, and I can't say I could see anything about this there.
If I didn't spend all my b***y spare time on here, the web site would be up to date. Best thing is to be on our mailing list.
Originally posted by David Franklin
So did this work better than your "official" advanced classes? I would think you'd get a better selection of dancers without having to bruise egos too badly.
Dave
Hard to tell, it was over a much longer period.
Adam
Routines
Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2003 4:00 am
by Gordon J Pownall
Yep - gotta agree with the boss...
Sally and I taught a choreographed routine in the swing room in Camber in November.
It was bloody heaving in there (forget the 250 dancer limit). We did get a great reception but for us, seeing that many people dancing a choreographed routine was amazing.
It didn't necessarily make better dancers of everyone - but all those who took part may have learnt a new move or two. I think everyone really enjoyed the experience and arguably got some experience of how easy it actually is to listen to the lyrics and feel of the music as opposed to just dancing to the beat. Most of the dancers there were far better than us anyway!!!
The routine we taught was choreographed to Mambo Italiano and was an entry level routine. More difficult routines might get a similar reception but Sally and I decided that fun was far more important than technical challenge.
We did have to cut quite a lot out of the teaching of style and flair aspects of dancing routines. Important in showcasing but not when you only have an hour and a half time limit!!!
Hope everyone enjoed it and with luck (and bribery) Sal and I will be at Bognor with another entry level routine in January 2004.
If anyone is interested, email
ceroc@hotmail.com for further information about the 2004 routine(s) (as well as Mambo Italiano and others if you wish)..
Regards....Gordon and Sal...xxx
Thanks for the warm welcome and amazing feedback to all those in our class by the way - amazing!!!
Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2003 5:08 am
by JamesGeary
Originally posted by Gadget
I think that learning {completley} by mimicry is worse than learning by scripts: This just results in a carbon copy of the mimic-ed artist.
errr... thats the only way I know how to learn. Ask Lily, I don't listen to anything she says, but if I can watch someone I can usually copy it. Adam (cerocmetro), Viktor, Amir and Marilene are even more that way. I've watched all 4 of them copy things from people without actually realising thats what they were doing.
I've seen in life and on video over 100 dancers that I've liked. So who am I a carbon copy of.
And why is that worse than learning by scripts (equivalent to learning a physical sport from a book)?
Posted: Sat Dec 13, 2003 2:09 pm
by Jon
Originally posted by Gadget
Gus asked how to incorporate "Advanced" lessons into a normal class:
Would it not be possable to scatter the advanced knowledge allong side the intermediate areas in the form of {eg}"As an alternative to just stepping here, try and hit the beat with your foot and follow the body through..." etceteras.
The tricky bit would be knowing where the balance lay between alienating the majority of 'intermediate' dancers and educating the rest of the 'advanced' dancers.
Trouble is everyone is at a different standard in the intermediate classes. To do advanced moves or styling may put off some people who find it too hard. For instance I was at a venue last night and too me the moves were old classic ceroc moves which were easy but nearly every lady I got in the class asked if I was ok with these moves as most of the men were not. Needless to say the lady que got short very quickly as they dropped out.
At charlton they once did 3 intermediate moves and showed how to link them then said the 4th move would be advanced and anyone not comfortable could sit it out. This format was mentioned before the class started so everyone knew what to expect and I thought it worked well and catered for everyone. If your lucky to have another hall then even better but prehaps then your'll end up with less people in the intermediate class because they think they are ready for advanced or that is the way to progress quickly.
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2003 10:02 am
by Gadget
Originally posted by JamesGeary
I've seen in life and on video over 100 dancers that I've liked. So who am I a carbon copy of.
I was taking it to the extreeme and imagining copying from only one source.
It actually reminds me of a Startreck TNG epesode {

} that Data was playing the violin and complaining that he would never be 'great' because all the bits were copies of great artists. Piccard pointed out that the selection and way they were put together was unique and just as individual as the artists themselves.
I conceed the point; mimicry is jsut as valid as "book" learning.
The main problem I find with any form of {physical} learning is trying to get your body to move and form the shapes you have in your mind. With no pictures or external reference to compare with, I would say that it's almost impossable to do. Although; in all martial arts films, there is always a reference to a written tome of knowledge to take 'advanced' pupils beyond the normal boundaries of skill; Is there a parallel?
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2003 12:52 pm
by Rachel
Originally posted by JamesGeary
... I've watched all 4 of them copy things from people without actually realising thats what they were doing.
I was reminded earlier (posting about Sarah @ Hipsters) about a conversation overheard between Marc and Punkfish. (I keep calling him Punkfish, as I don't know if he's Anthony or Antony).
Anyway, Punkfish was saying something about looking forward to watching Marc's dancing and picking up some moves. And Marc said, well, you'll recognise most of them, cos I stole them from you!
Nothing wrong with copying, I say!
R.