Page 4 of 9
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 9:31 am
by Andy McGregor
ChrisA wrote: I was very careful not to interfere with anyone else's dancing (and I certainly recall no bumps),
Hey Chris, I think it was me. I went around banging into people I knew, especially if they were gincing
But it was only a gentle nudge

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 11:21 am
by Bill
Simon r wrote:I have been keeping an eye on this thread and after Wednesday at Hipsters just thought I would add a little info:
Well firstly they may have slotted to a fashion, but the idea is to hold your line and not to cross on to other dancers lines and then snake across the floor. I was amazed just how poor their appreciation of other dancers was.
Interesting do you not think Mr Bond
I think this indicates a couple of assumptions ...firstly that all Hipsters' dancers are very good dancers (both lead and follow) and secondly there's room to 'slot' dance. There are some great dancers at Hipsters =- some of the best - but equally there are a number of new/inexperienced/ bad dancers there too.
I prefer the Wednesday because it's less busy and even trying to dance on a slot becomes difficult when there's not a lot of room.I've also seen some experienced dancers who take up a lot of room - perhaps because they feel they deserve the space ??? If we all danced like Davidb then we'd pack hundreds on the floor ..... big man.......great moves....small space

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 11:41 am
by Gadget
Simon r wrote:For those experts that have been telling us in great detail how their slotted dancing is superior...
I admit that a lot of the discussion has been for the pro's of "slotted" dancing - but that's the title of the thread.
I
like "circular" dancing - it flows and glides easily - getting "slotted" dancing to that level of smoothness is a huge challenge. The skill involved in actually dancing in this way primarily invloves being able to controll your partner's position on the floor: Once this skill is learned, you should be able to use it, no matter whether dancing "slotted","circular" or "squigally spiral thing", to make better use of your 'dance space'. {well, that's my theory anyway

}
Actually learning/practicing/dancing in slots means that your partner is on train tracks... anyone else on those tracks can be in danger of being run down (if the lead has limited floor-craft.) Dancing in one shape or another will not IMHO improve or detract from floor-craft skills. (Which I think was the remainder of your post)
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 12:07 pm
by under par
Gadget wrote:I admit that a lot of the discussion has been for the pro's of "slotted" dancing - but that's the title of the thread.
I
like "circular" dancing - it flows and glides easily - getting "slotted" dancing to that level of smoothness is a huge challenge. The skill involved in actually dancing in this way primarily invloves being able to controll your partner's position on the floor: Once this skill is learned, you should be able to use it, no matter whether dancing "slotted","circular" or "squigally spiral thing", to make better use of your 'dance space'. {well, that's my theory anyway

}
Actually learning/practicing/dancing in slots means that your partner is on train tracks... anyone else on those tracks can be in danger of being run down (if the lead has limited floor-craft.) Dancing in one shape or another will not IMHO improve or detract from floor-craft skills. (Which I think was the remainder of your post)
The discussion has been enlightening and I have now got my head around a new concept as a result.
I have practised the slotted style a lot recently and I have done so to the detriment of my other regular moves, which have slowly evaporated from my mind!
I could not dance totally slotted in the future because I like to use the floor to move around quite a lot too.
The contol I have learned from trying to dance slotted has been brilliant, using slight hand touch/compressions to move the follower can only improve my technique.
But it is the variety of music and styles that make MJ what we love.

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 12:18 pm
by Sheepman
Simon r wrote:telling us in great detail how their slotted dancing is superior
has anyone actually said that? (I do say that it is
safer) I think we've agreed that the better followers are much easier to dance in a slot with, but that's mostly a lead and follow thing. Is there a parallel with the smoking debate here? I would defend your right of freedom to dance how you like and endanger yourself, as long as it doesn't interfere with others.
And I thought I did a good job of avoiding interference

from Andy while I was west coasting

I came close to a couple of bumps on Wednesday, but my motto is - if there's space use it!
Greg
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 4:12 pm
by Jive Brummie
Slotted dancing is all well and good...and safe....and all that, but only if you're dancing in a good crowd, with other considerate dancers. It's pointless trying to dance a certain way, is it not, if mr & mrs X are giving it big-licks next to you without a care in the world.
Have to be honest, and must apologise if this has been said already, but i personally find purely slotted dancing very dull

Don't mean to sound offensive there. I just think that dancing permanently in a slot looks as if you're just doing travelling returns. I think a mixture of slotted and circular dancing hits the right spot.........it just looks, feels and seems far more dynamic and easy on the eye.
Just a thought.
J x x
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 4:41 pm
by Sheepman
Jive Brummie wrote:Have to be honest, and must apologise if this has been said already, but i personally find purely slotted dancing very dull
No offense taken, but to say that, it doesn't sound like you've ever seen Robert Cordoba in action (or Kyle & Sarah, etc, hopefully we'll get them over to this country sometime soon . . .)
Greg
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Fri Jul 09, 2004 4:54 pm
by spindr
Jive Brummie wrote:Slotted dancing is all well and good...and safe....and all that, but only if you're dancing in a good crowd, with other considerate dancers. It's pointless trying to dance a certain way, is it not, if mr & mrs X are giving it big-licks next to you without a care in the world.
I always dance a certain way when mr & mrs X are giving it big-licks next to mewithout a care in the world -- usually I try and move out of the way -- and if that's not possible I keep myself between them and my partner.
If you're dancing slotted-style your partner can still travel, e.g. if you do a right side pass when your follower is on your left (travelling return) and a left side pass (no common MJ equiv.) when your follower is on your right, then the leader can effectively stay in place and protect one edge of the slot, as a precautionary measure.
SpinDr.
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Sun Jul 11, 2004 1:35 pm
by Jive Brummie
Sheepman wrote:No offense taken, but to say that, it doesn't sound like you've ever seen Robert Cordoba in action (or Kyle & Sarah, etc, hopefully we'll get them over to this country sometime soon . . .)
Greg
Good. No offense intended.
Have to be honest yet again though. Whoever was dancing slotted and however great a couple they were, I'd still think it was dull....but all the best to Mr Cordoba, Kyle & Sarah etc etc.....enjoy your ......slots??!!
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Sun Jul 11, 2004 2:20 pm
by TheTramp
Ah. James.... I really think that you should wait and see before you say things like that.... I've only seen Robert and Deborah, and they are anything but dull....
(I've been told that I'm mainly a slotted dancer, so I apologise if I'm dull

)
Trampy
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Sun Jul 11, 2004 3:48 pm
by Zebra Woman
Jive Brummie wrote: I'd still think it was dull....
Dull? Dull?
Dull????
CANNOT COMPUTE
On the plus side Jive Brummie, I'll go wherever you lead me even if it is in circles all night.

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 12:39 pm
by Geordieed
Probably the best example anyone will see this year of slotted dancing will be at RebelYell this year. Jordan and Tatiana will be there this year. Plus anyone who saw Jodie and Paul would have seen how good it can look.
Can't wait
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 2:30 pm
by Trish
Gadget wrote:I admit that a lot of the discussion has been for the pro's of "slotted" dancing - but that's the title of the thread.
I
like "circular" dancing - it flows and glides easily - getting "slotted" dancing to that level of smoothness is a huge challenge. The skill involved in actually dancing in this way primarily invloves being able to controll your partner's position on the floor: Once this skill is learned, you should be able to use it, no matter whether dancing "slotted","circular" or "squigally spiral thing", to make better use of your 'dance space'. {well, that's my theory anyway

}
Actually learning/practicing/dancing in slots means that your partner is on train tracks... anyone else on those tracks can be in danger of being run down (if the lead has limited floor-craft.) Dancing in one shape or another will not IMHO improve or detract from floor-craft skills. (Which I think was the remainder of your post)
I have read all of this thread now (should really be getting on with my work!!!), and although I THINK I know what you're all talking about I can't be absolutely sure. Hopefully I'll meet up with one or other of you at some point and you can point it out to me to see if my understanding is correct.
Like Gadget, I also like circular dancing (if by that you mean being swirled round the floor in a haphazard fashion), or at least I like a mixture of styles when someone is dancing with me and I like to try to do a mixture of styles when leading. And like various people have said I don't really enjoy myself as much if whoever is leading is pinning me down to one small lane and not ever moving out of it. I do think though that this sometimes happens when the dancefloor is crowded. I tend to find if I'm leading and can do it, that if the spot I'm in is crowded I will do something like a very long columbian or a rather linear type of triple step and try to move somewhere less crowded (if poss.) Does that make me a slotted dancer if I then twirl the girl in a circle when I get there? Can't work this out!

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 5:56 pm
by DavidB
3 points
If you watch a really good WCS couple, you won't see the lady sticking rigidly to a narrow slot. She will be in the slot when she needs to be - ie at the start of a move, and when she goes past the man. Other than that, her path could be anywhere bounded by a figure-8.
Although slotted dancing can take up less space at the sides, it frequently takes up *more* space down the length of the slot. And especially when the man decides not to move, the whole length of the slot is not occupied all the time. It will look like lots of free space to those dancing near you.
On those rare occasions where there is space, don't keep the lady just going from A to B and back again. Occasionally lengthen the slot, and go to C. Or take the scenic route, and deliberately lead the lady in a big circle for a change.
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 6:18 pm
by Banana Man
Geordieed wrote:....Plus anyone who saw Jodie and Paul would have seen how good it can look.

Jodie and Paul were at MJC, fab WCS, style and technique workshops, and to top it off a stunning cabaret.
IMHO learning or understanding a variety of styles gives you more scope, can make it more interesting for you and your partner, and keep you both safe on the dance floor - usually

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 6:49 pm
by Minnie M
Geordieed wrote:Probably the best example anyone will see this year of slotted dancing will be at RebelYell this year. Jordan and Tatiana will be there this year. Plus anyone who saw Jodie and Paul would have seen how good it can look.
Can't wait
Have you lot been sleeping for the past couple of years
Paul does look good when dancing and he looks fab with both Jody and Sally BUT .............
Remember Robert & Deborah at RebelYell 2002 & 2003 (the 2002 cabaret which was in fact freestyle was REALLY amazing) and what about Lily and David B - hasn't anyone seen them freestyling - IMO they are by far the best West Coast Swing couple we have in this country
Paul might be more visual than David (he has more hip movements) however David is a much better lead, and Lily's style and grace puts Jody in the novice corner AND we would not have West Coast Swing over here if it wasn't for David & Lily they have kept it alive and worked very hard at keeping it there - please please give them the credit they truly deserve

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Mon Jul 12, 2004 11:19 pm
by Gordon J Pownall
Minnie M wrote:Have you lot been sleeping for the past couple of years
AND we would not have West Coast Swing over here if it wasn't for David & Lily they have kept it alive and worked very hard at keeping it there - please please give them the credit they truly deserve
Although I don't do west coast (more of an east coast myself (cos it's easier)), I do know that by reputation alone, David and Lilly have brought WCS alive in the UK and kept it alive.......(IMHO)....

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Tue Jul 13, 2004 12:36 pm
by Banana Man
Minnie M wrote:Have you lot been sleeping for the past couple of years
..... we would not have West Coast Swing over here if it wasn't for David & Lily they have kept it alive and worked very hard at keeping it there - please please give them the credit they truly deserve
Not sleeping, just not doing MJ for that long, so not aware of who's done what, forgive the ignorance. Knew a bit about David and Lily's background in Ballroom/Latin, thought their Classes at Fulham were fantastic

, always try to get a dance with Lily at Jive Bar

Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Tue Jul 13, 2004 1:14 pm
by Minnie M

apologies to all who HAVE mentioned Robert & Deborah and have stated how great they are - I just saw red that nobody mentioned our own 'home grown' D & L as since MJC all I have heard is Paul & Jody, Paul & Jody again and again - not that they aren't good, but credit were credits due.
However, I did fly off the handle without reading the other posts properly and a couple of you have mentioned the 'yanks' - my personal favourites are Kyle & Sarah. I am very honoured to say I have danced with both Jordon & Kyle, both amazing dancers and great leads, however Kyle made me feel special and therefore I danced better with him AND I just liked K & S style more (a bit funcky)
Re: Slotted Dancing
Posted: Tue Jul 13, 2004 2:01 pm
by bigdjiver
Minnie M wrote: my personal favourites are Kyle & Sarah. I am very honoured to say I have danced with both Jordon & Kyle, both amazing dancers and great leads, however Kyle made me feel special and therefore I danced better with him AND I just liked K & S style more (a bit funcky)
I have seen too little of KYle, but what I have is very inspirational to me. Being of lumbering brute proportions, I am curious. Kyle looks tall with Sarah. How tall is he?