Page 1 of 6

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:40 am
by ChrisA
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Ok, ceroc produces many advanced dancers!
Question: How?

I'm not disputing it, I'm asking how it does it. Intermediate classes? Surely not. Style workshops? Er... CTA training? Dunno, haven't done it.

So I say again: exactly HOW does Ceroc produce advanced dancers?

Cos I want some.

Chris

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 2:08 am
by cerocmetro
Originally posted by ChrisA
Question: How?

I'm not disputing it, I'm asking how it does it. Intermediate classes? Surely not. Style workshops? Er... CTA training? Dunno, haven't done it.

So I say again: exactly HOW does Ceroc produce advanced dancers?

Cos I want some.

Chris


Glad you asked, great question and I am sure my response will be controversial. Firstly are we talking advanced dancers ie those who know some tough moves or great dancers? I assume the latter

Great dancers come from two sources, a) naturally b) with huge amounts of practice.

I have been teachng, ooo a long time. Let me put my neck on the line here. I have spotted great dancers on their first or second night even if they could not dance. I have offered 5 people the chance to teach within a week of joining Ceroc. They are naturals. You can feel when you take someones hand if they have the "x-factor" touch.

I ran an x-factor workshop. The idea was to take dancers from one level to the next. It was a huge success. Everyone loved it. They all improved. Without wishing to upset anyone though, one person on that course will be a great dancers and that person was a great dancer before they did the course. The others will all be good intermediate dancers/advanced dancers

From my experience, great dancers are few and far between. You can tell who they are. You can tell as they walk onto the floor, even before they "draw a semi circle to the left" :devil:

People do not need advanced classes or workshops to become great dancers. IMO they probably never will. What they will become are competent dancers. Advanced dancers do not need advanced classes, they need good intermediate classes, workshops and a huge amount of time on the dance floor.

I can teach music interpretation till the cows come home, slick moves, technique etc etc, but you have to have the ability to use those tools before you start.

Ceroc is for enjoyment and pleasure. Take it too seriously and it fails. I asked a question today for a TV programme. "who has met a partner at Ceroc?" I have had back in 7 hours over 1100 replies. That is what Ceroc is, it is a social event, where you learn how to dance to a competent level. In a fun environment.

Going back to the original question, you either have it or you ain't. That does not mean you cannot be a good dancer, that means you may not be a great dancer. When I say great I am talking maybe less than 5% of Cerocers/MJers.

The teachers have to be great teachers, that is essential, if they are not, they are letting you down.

I see many dancers who say to me I went to a great class/workshop, dance holiday whatever and learnt so much. Does it improve their dancing, I hope they believe it does.

Great dancers dance less than 20 moves. That is how I see it. They dance with the music. You cannot teach this you have to feel it. You can teach breaks etc etc but you have to feel it. If you need to be taught it, .... well that speaks for itself. What you can learn is to appreciate it.

Don't confuse learning set pieces and think that is great dancing. It is not. To be a great dancer/artist you have to suffer. You have to work out. I challange you to find one "great" dancer who is not on massive amounts of painkillers and lives with oesteos and bandages.

Maybe you should define what you mean by advanced dancers. Maybe I have been too hard.

I hope this has gone someway to answer your question. If not, then come to one of my workshops :wink:

Adam

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 2:15 am
by bigdjiver
Originally posted by ChrisA
Question: How?

I'm not disputing it, I'm asking how it does it. Intermediate classes? Surely not. Style workshops? Er... CTA training? Dunno, haven't done it.

So I say again: exactly HOW does Ceroc produce advanced dancers?

Cos I want some.

Chris


Dancers have ideas, share ideas, try ideas, discard the ones that do not cut it, generate new ideas from the ones that do.

There is no past super-race that were alone capable of inventing, developing, defining and propagating a form of dance. With the advent of video the process is accelerating. We learn from each other.

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 3:01 am
by ChrisA
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Glad you asked, great question and I am sure my response will be controversial.
Adam
For the record, I was greatly taken by Adam's post.

I don't know the guy, but what he wrote made a lot of sense to me.

Chris

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 3:05 am
by JamesGeary
Originally posted by cerocmetro

I have spotted great dancers on their first or second night even if they could not dance....
...you either have it or you ain't...

Adam


True. You can tell instantly. Its like when girls say "I don't know that move", its not about the move its about their responsiveness. I've danced with people who have never danced previously and never had to teach them a move, they just reacted. I know exactly what you mean.

But when I query their background 95% of them have had 10 years previous dance experience or 10 years experience in something involving lots of body control (tai-chi, martial arts, aerobics, gymnastics, ice-skating, rollerblading).

That might seem to indicate that anything can be taught.

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 3:12 am
by ChrisA
Originally posted by JamesGeary
That might seem to indicate that anything can be taught.
Believing this is what keeps me alive, James.

Chris

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 3:18 am
by cerocmetro
Originally posted by JamesGeary
True. You can tell instantly. Its like when girls say "I don't know that move", its not about the move its about their responsiveness. I've danced with people who have never danced previously and never had to teach them a move, they just reacted. I know exactly what you mean.

James didn't you win lots of dosh off me at my Masked Ball competition with one of my taxi dancers who had been dancing for only a few weeks?

Was that because she was a good dancer??? :wink: The fact she was wearing less than what you were wearing on the beach today had nothing to do with it??

Adam
ps ask if Webb Ellis is around when next on the beach :devil:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 3:24 am
by ChrisA
Er... someone encouraged me to post this.
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Great dancers come from two sources, a) naturally b) with huge amounts of practice.

Hi Adam.

I like you. I reckon we'd get along well. I hate you, you b****d.

Guess what - I agree with all this stuff.

Guess what else? I'm not a great dancer by your definition. Guess how I feel, knowing that?

That is what Ceroc is, it is a social event, where you learn how to dance to a competent level. In a fun environment.

Don't give me this. Of course you're right - and, big time, you're wrong, and you know it.

The teachers have to be great teachers, that is essential, if they are not, they are letting you down.

In my life, I've noticed this... I end up teaching everything I do. I've taught organic chemistry to emergency case A-level and undergraduate students. I've taught some A-level maths and some other stuff for which, technically I'm unqualified.

Oh yeah, and I teach some beginners jive. Mostly I do a good job. And where I don't, I learn.

I love to teach. There is nothing that affirms my achievement more than the success of my students.

Will that do?

Maybe I have been too hard.

How would that be possible?

I hope this has gone someway to answer your question.

Not really. Though you've confirmed what I knew, deep down.

Oh yeah.. this "huge amounts of practice" thing. I can relate to that. Maybe I won't kill myself tonight.

Chris

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 8:50 am
by Minnie M
Welcome to the thread Adam - it is very refreshing to read positive posts :kiss: :cheers: :hug:

Can we go inside now please :grin:

Your video really IS the best I have ever seen

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 9:47 am
by RobC
Originally posted by Minnie M
Your video really IS the best I have ever seen

Perhaps I should start plugging my MJC7 video (and DVD) :devil:

Rob

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 10:31 am
by David Franklin
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Great dancers come from two sources, a) naturally b) with huge amounts of practice.
Agreed. Though I don't think anyone becomes great without a lot of practice. (or previous experience). But you then say:
Going back to the original question, you either have it or you ain't. That does not mean you cannot be a good dancer, that means you may not be a great dancer. When I say great I am talking maybe less than 5% of Cerocers/MJers.
Don't know if I'm misunderstanding you, but you now seem to be saying no amount of practice will make you a great dancer. At the highest level I might agree (might not - I think it depends on the arena), but to be in the top 5%? I think that's very achievable for almost anyone who wants to put in the work. [It occurs to me you may be meaning only 5% have the potential to be great. In which case forget I said anything...]

As a data point, I've seen footage of Nigel competing in '98 (and in the teachers section, so he wasn't a beginner). The transformation between him then and even a couple of years later is absolutely huge. It shows what hard work can achieve.
The teachers have to be great teachers, that is essential, if they are not, they are letting you down.
Just to be controversial, I'll make the observation that the people who win or place at championships are predominantly not Ceroc (UK) taught[*]. What does that say about the teaching?

[*]To be fair, a lot have done Ceroc and may have started there. But if you look at when they started *winning*, you find it's when they started getting outside input.
I see many dancers who say to me I went to a great class/workshop, dance holiday whatever and learnt so much. Does it improve their dancing, I hope they believe it does.
I think a lot of stuff from workshops doesn't stick, or doesn't help. But the first time you learn "oh, you're supposed to do something different when the music changes", or that there's more to leading than moving your hands, or that there are other dance organizations than the one you normally go to; those are all important realisations.
Great dancers dance less than 20 moves. That is how I see it. They dance with the music. You cannot teach this you have to feel it. You can teach breaks etc etc but you have to feel it. If you need to be taught it, .... well that speaks for itself. What you can learn is to appreciate it.
Sorry, but I think this is rubbish. The best dancer I have ever seen (was getting partnership offers from ballroom pros within 2 years of starting, and in terms of solo movement could blow away anyone I've seen in the Modern Jive world) didn't even know what a break was. It just wasn't in the concepts he was used to dealing with. He had to be taught.
Don't confuse learning set pieces and think that is great dancing. It is not. To be a great dancer/artist you have to suffer. You have to work out. I challange you to find one "great" dancer who is not on massive amounts of painkillers and lives with oesteos and bandages.
Although I agree with the general sentiments, we seem to have moved a long way from "great ~= top 5% of MJ dancers" with that last sentence! [And though I know where you're coming from it's been almost a year since I saw my osteopath - sorting my technique helped a lot...]

Dave

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 10:48 am
by Minnie M
Originally posted by RobC
Perhaps I should start plugging my MJC7 video (and DVD) :devil:
Rob


I will be a Bisley tonight Rob, let me have a copy and I will post my opinion of it - I know the content will be good as it was a great weekend :wink:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 11:48 am
by Andy McGregor
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Great dancers dance less than 20 moves. That is how I see it. They dance with the music. You cannot teach this you have to feel it. You can teach breaks etc etc but you have to feel it. If you need to be taught it, .... well that speaks for itself. What you can learn is to appreciate it.

To be a great dancer/artist you have to suffer. You have to work out. I challange you to find one "great" dancer who is not on massive amounts of painkillers and lives with oesteos and bandages.


YIPPEE!!!

Just need to learn another 2 moves and I'll be great :waycool:

I agree with Adam, I'll probably never be 'great' but as I've progressed from 'hopeless beginner who couldn't find the beat' I've done less and less moves and more and more playing with the music.

And I have taken more and more painkillers and visited the Osteopath more - even had to go to A&E once after snapping my hamstring doing the splits :tears:




But, taking this seriously for a moment - but initially being slightly fippant and provocative. If what Adam says is true we might as well give up wanting to become great dancers - Adam can just hold our hand and advise us that we're going to be great - or that we're not. Which of course is partly right but an oversimplification. What Adam's talking about is people who will be very quick to learn becaue they've already 'got' a lot of what dance and lead-and-follow is all about. But us others can also 'get' it. There is a saying 'If one person can do something, anyone can learn to do it'. That doesn't mean we will be the 'greatest but we can be 'great' (I hope..). Us others will just need to work very hard learning what the already 'great' people know. And that could be a very long road for those of us that need to unlearn loads of stuff before they can even start learning. Starting dancing after 15 years of fencing and 12 years of Karate/Tae Kwon-do/Kung-Fu I first had to learn to call them my 'partner' not 'opponent'...

So can we all be great dancers? YES, YES, YES! But we might have to put in so much work everything else in our lives would have to go on hold while we do it. The question should be 'How much are we willing to give and give up to become great dancers?'.

There is another question which is 'Can we be the greatest dancer/couple?'. I have one answer and one question in response to this.

The answer for everyone except one person or couple is 'NO'. The reason is that there can only be one 'greatest' at any one time and that person/couple has learnt all the right things (in the eyes of the judges, but that's another thread) and practiced them more and been more motivated, etc. Did they have a head start due to 'natural' talent that wasn't due to 'nurture'? That is a whole other debate too.

And the question I mentioned above is 'Why would I want to be the greatest? - I only go dancing for fun and I want to have the greatest fun I can have.'


:devil: Serious mode off :devil:

And if Adam is correct about the 20 moves thing I now have a new explanation for why people turn up and sit out the lesson. They already know 19 moves and don't want to stop being great by learning another 3 :wink:

Anyone else got any idea why people turn up in time for the lesson and positively don't do it - they even do this on a Tuesday at Hipsters. Do they think they're so good they don't need it? :devil:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 12:54 pm
by Minnie M
Sorry I forgot this is outside and can't edit - should have added a IMHO to my dancing status - I know I am not a great dancer, but I am quite happy with that.

The moves that need to be taught at my level IMHO and for a follower, all seem to be 'wrap arounds' or lifts and drops - no one will want to do those with me anyway !

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 12:57 pm
by Mikey
Originally posted by Minnie M
Sorry I forgot this is outside and can't edit - should have added a IMHO to my dancing status - I know I am not a great dancer, but I am quite happy with that.

The moves that need to be taught at my level IMHO and for a follower, all seem to be 'wrap arounds' or lifts and drops - no one will want to do those with me anyway !


Excuse me ? but may i remind you that due to your ability as an experienced dancer, many times i have seduced you :wink: :hug:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:00 pm
by Minnie M
Originally posted by Mikey
Excuse me ? but may i remind you that due to your ability as an experienced dancer, many times i have seduced you :wink: :hug:


Ah yes I remember it well :drool: and in public too (your birthday dance at Hipsters) - you are a very strong bad boy :yum:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:06 pm
by Lory
Originally posted by cerocmetro
Great dancers come from two sources, a) naturally b) with huge amounts of practice.

I have been teachng, ooo a long time. Let me put my neck on the line here. I have spotted great dancers on their first or second night even if they could not dance. I have offered 5 people the chance to teach within a week of joining Ceroc. They are naturals. You can feel when you take someones hand if they have the "x-factor" touch.

Adam


I sadly have to agree with this (sadly, for the reason, I have to accept I'll never be 'great')

I can back Adams answer up though.......

I took my 16 (nearly 17) year old daughter for the first time to Ceroc a couple of months ago, she'd never done any form of partner dance before but she had done various other disciplines, like ballet, jazz, tap, street dance and gymnastics.

She hadn't a clue about the leads and the only advise I could offer her was, just look for the 'hand' grab it and let your self follow where it leads u.

I have to say, she looked fantastic, I know I'm biased but when someone does a triple spin with absolute ease, poise and balance on their first night, it has to add up to something!

She danced with Mikey and ended up making a huge mistake, sort of diving forwards into a drop but because she did it with such grace and poise (and attitude) and he's experienced enough to react and make something out of it, they ended up getting a round of applause and out of a mistake a 'new move' was born.

She's now been 4 times! Watch this space!

Natural body awareness, balance, style, rhythm, musical interpretation, little touches, like whipping the head on turns, hand movements, pointed feet and deportment are things that are instinctive in 'great' dancers.

If you have all that, your 75% on your way to making a 'great' dancer before you've ever even danced with a partner :cheers:

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:26 pm
by cerocmetro
Originally posted by Lory
I sadly have to agree with this (sadly, for the reason, I have to accept I'll never be 'great')

I can back Adams answer up though.......

I took my 16 (nearly 17) year old daughter for the first time to Ceroc a couple of months ago, she'd never done any form of partner dance before but she had done various other disciplines, like ballet, jazz, tap, street dance and gymnastics.


If you have all that, your 75% on your way to making a 'great' dancer before you've ever even danced with a partner :cheers:


Does she want to think about teaching, for CerocMetro of course? I will be at Finchley next Monday night?

Whilst here Lory, you mentioned the advanced classes we tried. We gave up on them because suddenly everyone was an advanced dancer. It became clear the only way to cater to this market was in small groups, hence the X-factor classes I taught there. Were you aware of these. I took 20 people on a six week course. The idea was to take them up a level. Most of them went up several levels.

I am going to run it again in the New year. For you guys in Scotland, it included the music interp workshop I did in Perth and a whole lot more. It included, spinning, every week, lead and follow, posture, move progression, move selection, body control. We even discussed the effect of different shoes and dance floors and how they can effect your style.

It was as about advanced as it gets. What made it work so well was that everyone committed to the 6 weeks. Therefore they were there to do the classes and really wanted to learn.

What they learnt was great, but it is up to them to now put all the hard work in.

Let me offer a shred of hope to some I may have upset. Most people can become advanced dancers. A few can become great dancers. The majority of the few will have natural ability, the minority will be coached, BUT, they will be the ones who work at it.

Adam

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:27 pm
by Mary
Going back a bit I would quite like to respond to Adam's reply about 'teaching' dancers to become great dancers. Thoroughly enjoyed reading this Adam. You have a great way of expressing things.

I agree that some dancers have 'it' (bastards!) - wot, me, jealous? Nah. However to become great does take hard work, and a fair amount of teaching. OK, maybe teaching is the wrong word. I suppose I would use the word 'introducing' ideas such as playing with the music, using your body to create shapes, and connection. I think it's a question of teaching these ideas then their natural talent and ability lets these ideas come into visual shape dancing-wise. You cannot 'teach' improvisation, dance dialogue, but you can point people in the right direction. Some will take a few unsure, tottering steps,others may be able to trot reasonable comfortably, but those who have 'it' will be able to sprint without breaking sweat!! Don't you just hate 'em! :wink:

Gosh, I wish I could write. :what:

BTW. Great jivemasters video. Waxed a bit more lyrical about it in another thread. Loads of inspiration. Cheers mate. :cheers:

I think I will go now before I confuse myself.:sorry

M

Posted: Fri Dec 12, 2003 1:53 pm
by David Franklin
Originally posted by Lory
I took my 16 (nearly 17) year old daughter for the first time to Ceroc a couple of months ago, she'd never done any form of partner dance before but she had done various other disciplines, like ballet, jazz, tap, street dance and gymnastics.

I have to say, she looked fantastic, I know I'm biased but when someone does a triple spin with absolute ease, poise and balance on their first night, it has to add up to something!.
Sounds like she's going to be a star! If she's done "ballet, jazz, tap, street dance and gymnastics" that puts her ahead of 95% of Ceroc dancers already. I know I found street jazz a harder test of my spinning than Ceroc ever was!

I think there are different "aspects" to being a good partner dancer - some that come to mind are lead and follow, quality of movement and musical interpretation. Of these, I think "quality of movement" is the one that's a killer to learn, and it's the thing that "natural" dancers seem to have in spades over the rest of us. I'm not clear how much it can be learned (Jazz/Street dancers seem to have it in spades - but how many give up those classes because they don't "have it"?). Is it something you can only really learn when you're young?

Looking at the "next generation" of Ceroc dancers - the people who started in their teens - I think we're going to see a completely new level of dancing. Just hope there's still a place for the rest of us...

Dave