Weight and size in Ceroc / MJ
Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2003 6:26 pm
This thread has been prompted not so much by some very important issues that have been recognised on the 'Body Image' thread but by several posts in other threads.
A short (true) story to illustrate:
At a Scottish dance night, a New Zealand woman I was dancing with (that I had just met) said to me: "Guys over here don't do an drops with me - do they think I'm not capable or something?"
I instinctively knew why no guys were doing drops with her:
She was 5'11" and fairly heavy set and large-boned. She probably weighed a bit more than me.
She was an experienced intermediate dancer. More to the point for me, she was NZ trained. I immediately flashed her a smile, "I'll do drops with you." (I quite like doing drops).
Needless to say, she did everything I threw at her correctly.
No woman should feel she has to avoid a class that contains drops because of her weight
There are very few drops in my experience that involve strength if correctly executed. There are very few drops where a follower's weight is a deciding factor if executed correctly.
The truth is, almost no Ceroc / MJ outfits in the UK bother teaching technique firmly and correctly. (I have pussyfooted around saying it is just 'different' but the truth is UK Ceroc and many MJ groups are unintentionally marginalising people - and this is just an instance. See my post here for my own attempt to explain it.)
It is no good saying 'we sort of cover that' - 'sort of' is no good. It is not an advanced technique or a style extra, it is something that should be taught as a drill so that everyone starting to learn drops knows it.
It is not difficult. It could easily be written into the Ceroc bible. (Just as the very useful and not unreleated anti-yank change suggested by DaveB "Semicircle with the hand, step back, and stop yourself!" needs to be incorporated from the first lesson - not as some high-falutin technique that people might be able to follow eventually.)
Ladies (and especially heavier ladies - and their partners), if you want to learn, I can think of a few teachers on the circuit that can be relied on to teach you this properly: (Get a private lesson or just ask them for three minutes - the basics don't take long to teach.)
Amir Giles
Nigel & Nina
James Geary (Haven't seen him teach personally but having learnt it in NZ he's not likely to have forgotten.)
Adam & Mandy (Haven't seen him teach drops but with NZ Mandy keeping an eye on him he's hardly going to teach it wrong.)
Teachers: To brush up your technique without going public, Nina Daines is also an excellent teacher-trainer. I can't imagine DavidB not being in both categories too but he's not a regular teacher (sadly for us!)
No offence to top teachers I haven't mentioned - it is not a reflection on your dance teaching, nor is it an 'advanced' technique - but you either do it or you don't - there's no 'sort of.'
In the UK there is an emphasis on fun that is great, but there are times when people need something explained in no uncertain terms, not as 'fun'. You would not teach how to wire a plug as 'fun.'
Ceroc Ltd: Angelique Meyer (NZ Ceroc Founder) is over in the UK next year. This would be an excellent time to learn, and update the standard syllabus, without losing face. And unlike the UK and Australian outfits, she has not been hampered by competition that tends to increase the 'we know best' belief (or is it just Kiwis' natural tendency to self-effacement?)
Remember - Ceroc isn't Microsoft:
Microsoft learns.
Let's hope that under Mike Ellard Ceroc will grow, instead of too often believing its own hype . . .
A short (true) story to illustrate:
At a Scottish dance night, a New Zealand woman I was dancing with (that I had just met) said to me: "Guys over here don't do an drops with me - do they think I'm not capable or something?"
I instinctively knew why no guys were doing drops with her:
She was 5'11" and fairly heavy set and large-boned. She probably weighed a bit more than me.
She was an experienced intermediate dancer. More to the point for me, she was NZ trained. I immediately flashed her a smile, "I'll do drops with you." (I quite like doing drops).
Needless to say, she did everything I threw at her correctly.
No woman should feel she has to avoid a class that contains drops because of her weight
There are very few drops in my experience that involve strength if correctly executed. There are very few drops where a follower's weight is a deciding factor if executed correctly.
The truth is, almost no Ceroc / MJ outfits in the UK bother teaching technique firmly and correctly. (I have pussyfooted around saying it is just 'different' but the truth is UK Ceroc and many MJ groups are unintentionally marginalising people - and this is just an instance. See my post here for my own attempt to explain it.)
It is no good saying 'we sort of cover that' - 'sort of' is no good. It is not an advanced technique or a style extra, it is something that should be taught as a drill so that everyone starting to learn drops knows it.
It is not difficult. It could easily be written into the Ceroc bible. (Just as the very useful and not unreleated anti-yank change suggested by DaveB "Semicircle with the hand, step back, and stop yourself!" needs to be incorporated from the first lesson - not as some high-falutin technique that people might be able to follow eventually.)
Ladies (and especially heavier ladies - and their partners), if you want to learn, I can think of a few teachers on the circuit that can be relied on to teach you this properly: (Get a private lesson or just ask them for three minutes - the basics don't take long to teach.)
Amir Giles
Nigel & Nina
James Geary (Haven't seen him teach personally but having learnt it in NZ he's not likely to have forgotten.)
Adam & Mandy (Haven't seen him teach drops but with NZ Mandy keeping an eye on him he's hardly going to teach it wrong.)
Teachers: To brush up your technique without going public, Nina Daines is also an excellent teacher-trainer. I can't imagine DavidB not being in both categories too but he's not a regular teacher (sadly for us!)
No offence to top teachers I haven't mentioned - it is not a reflection on your dance teaching, nor is it an 'advanced' technique - but you either do it or you don't - there's no 'sort of.'
In the UK there is an emphasis on fun that is great, but there are times when people need something explained in no uncertain terms, not as 'fun'. You would not teach how to wire a plug as 'fun.'
Ceroc Ltd: Angelique Meyer (NZ Ceroc Founder) is over in the UK next year. This would be an excellent time to learn, and update the standard syllabus, without losing face. And unlike the UK and Australian outfits, she has not been hampered by competition that tends to increase the 'we know best' belief (or is it just Kiwis' natural tendency to self-effacement?)
Remember - Ceroc isn't Microsoft:
Microsoft learns.
Let's hope that under Mike Ellard Ceroc will grow, instead of too often believing its own hype . . .