Israel v Lebanon

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
Post Reply
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Msfab wrote:Your term 'Hizb-ut-Tahrir' actually means 'party of freedom' which is different to 'party of God'
But the 'Hizb' bit is the same, isn't it?
Will wrote:With regards to the timing of the crisis, there is a lot of speculation that Hezbollah wanted to test out the new Israeli leader to see if he might be a bit weaker than Sharon and be blackmailed into releasing Hezbollah Millitants in return for Israeli soldiers. I also wonder if the strength of the response on this first major crisis since Ehud Olmert took over is designed to answer any questions in Hezbollahs mind about the new Israeli leaderships resolve.
This is no doubt all true also.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Msfab
Senior Member
Posts: 1104
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 2:32 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Msfab »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:But the 'Hizb' bit is the same, isn't it?

Yes - Hizb is party/group
Ditch the diplomacy, let’s dance!

Smile...It confuses people (Sandi Thom):D
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

Baruch wrote:Although there may be controversy over Israel's chosen methods, bear in mind that Hizbollah, not Israel, started hostilities by staging a cross-border raid on an Israeli patrol.
NEWSFLASH. With the continuing threat from the 'Real' IRA operating from Eire the British Government took somewhat controversial but highly effective action to ensure future cessation of terrorist activity.

When asked to comment on why what was formerly known as Eire was now a smouldering radioactive wasteland, the Government spokesperson explained that whilst Eire had not taken appropriate action the British government was compelled to act in the interests of National Security. The idea for such a complete approach was apparently inspired by the current 'little spat' out in the Middle East

When queried on the point that much of the funding came from the US of A the spokesman smiled warmly and, after checking his watch, confirmed that the funding would also cease to be an issue ... in 3 minutes and 30 seconds .. if the Tridents lived up the makers guarantees.
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

mikeyr wrote:
El Salsero Gringo wrote:Syria moved 40,000 troops into Lebanon as early as 1976, in an alliance with the Maronite Christians.
Thats true, How many did that increase to, once the Israeli occupation started and were the clashes in the Bekaa territorial?
I couldn't find any data on this, except I've just noticed this comment on the BBC website
BBC News wrote:...despite UN resolution 1559, passed in 2004, which called for the disarming of militias as well as the withdrawal of foreign (i.e about 14,000 Syrian) forces from Lebanon.
So in 2004, 14,000 troops. I can't find any record of the peak Syrian military presence in Lebanon, or when it might have occured, but I will keep looking.

Edit: OK, this site: http://www.cfr.org/publication/7851/middle_east.html

has the following information:

How long have Syrian troops been in Lebanon?

Since 1976. Full-scale civil war broke out in April 1975 between the Maronite Christian groups of the Lebanese Front and the Lebanese National Movement, which was made up of left-leaning Muslims who wanted a greater share of political power. Fighting was intense, and in June 1976 the Maronite-dominated government asked for support from Syria.

[then, later]

"Syria maintains that its troops--whose numbers reached a high of 35,000-40,000 in 2000--are a stabilizing factor and claims it would withdraw them immediately if Lebanon asked."


So your inference that Syrian intervention in Lebanon can be laid at Israel's door seems doubtful.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
mikeyr
Senior Member
Posts: 507
Joined: Thu Jan 22, 2004 11:00 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by mikeyr »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:.So your inference that Syrian intervention in Lebanon can be laid at Israel's door seems doubtful.
The Golan Heights - Occupied since 1967 and still considered by the international community to be Israeli occupied Syrian territory.

Numerous border clashes over the years.

Continued Violation of Syrian sovereign airspace by IAF.


If these are not a good reasons for trying to influence government in a country that would allow you to put troops on your enemies northern border. They may not be the stated objectives of the Syrian government of the time but I would be surprised if they were not considered.


With the current conflict is entering a new more disturbing stage of IDF ground troops moving in to southern Lebanon, these historical parallels begin to look like deja vu.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

mikeyr wrote:The Golan Heights - Occupied since 1967 and still considered by the international community to be Israeli occupied Syrian territory.

Numerous border clashes over the years.

Continued Violation of Syrian sovereign airspace by IAF.
And each of these has it's own causes. One can follow this chain back as far as you like, but I'm not one of those conspiracy theorists or (journalists for The Independent) who enjoys this game of "Whatever it is, let's contrive a way to blame it on Israel". There are always (at least) two sides to any conflict.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
mikeyr
Senior Member
Posts: 507
Joined: Thu Jan 22, 2004 11:00 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by mikeyr »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:And each of these has it's own causes. One can follow this chain back as far as you like, but I'm not one of those conspiracy theorists or (journalists for The Independent) who enjoys this game of "Whatever it is, let's contrive a way to blame it on Israel". There are always (at least) two sides to any conflict.
I agree with you, Iam sure we could take this all the way back to the Old testament. and yes I would say there were other peoples Geo-political interests being played out in this region. Iam definately not blaming Israel for starting anything. It is, however, in my opinion some of their conduct since that I have issue.
with.
Barry Shnikov
Senior Member
Posts: 6709
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Barry Shnikov »

mikeyr wrote:I agree with you, Iam sure we could take this all the way back to the Old testament. and yes I would say there were other peoples Geo-political interests being played out in this region. Iam definately not blaming Israel for starting anything. It is, however, in my opinion some of their conduct since that I have issue.
with.
I never made that link before.

The jewish faith teaches that God took Israel away from whoever lived there and gave it to the Jews once before, back in Pentateuchal days. Possibly that makes it easy for many of them to believe it was OK to reiterate the process in the twentieth century.

Hands up - who thinks 'Pentateuchal' is a word? Or should it be 'Pentateuchish'?


Pentateuchist?
Let go of my hands and for God's sake STOP BOUNCING!
Barry Shnikov
Senior Member
Posts: 6709
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Barry Shnikov »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Israeli military action in Lebanon aims to reduce the capability of Hizbullah to target northern and other Israeli towns with Iranian rockets, as well as counter Hizbullah's attempt to redefine itself (and therefore its paymaster Iran) as a dominant player in the Middle East.
Reasonably mystified as to how aerial bombardment/missile strikes on Beirut are supposed to achieve that. I wouldn't especially approve of a surgical strike on southern Lebanon to achieve that effect, but it would make more sense that bombing shit out of the capital city.
Let go of my hands and for God's sake STOP BOUNCING!
User avatar
Stuart M
Senior Member
Posts: 2042
Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2002 4:52 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Stuart M »

Barry Shnikov wrote:'Pentateuchish'?
Linguistic coincidence probably, but isn't this is Gaelic?

"adj. behaviour after 5 beers"
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Barry Shnikov wrote:Possibly that makes it easy for many of them to believe it was OK to reiterate the process in the twentieth century.
Suffice it to say that's a beautifully trite, and one-sided sound-bite of a situation that I know that you at least (unlike some people contributing to this thread) are intelligent enough to understand better. How disappointing.
Barry Shnikov wrote:Reasonably mystified as to how aerial bombardment/missile strikes on Beirut are supposed to achieve that. I wouldn't especially approve of a surgical strike on southern Lebanon to achieve that effect, but it would make more sense that bombing shit out of the capital city.
I don't think it's important to anyone with their finger behind the trigger as to whether you're mystified or not.

If Israel wanted to "bomb the shit out of the capital city" - you can bet that's what they'd be doing. As it is, what I think you're watching is a large collection of surgical strikes against targets in all sorts of areas where intelligence suggests Hezbollah arms and personnel are stored.

You might or might not approve of the strategy, and the inevitable civilian deaths it is causing. But this is not mindless targetting of random buildings and vehicles in the middle of a city.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
azande
Senior Member
Posts: 1541
Joined: Fri Jan 24, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by azande »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:As it is, what I think you're watching is a large collection of surgical strikes against targets in all sorts of areas where intelligence suggests Hezbollah arms and personnel are stored
:rofl: :shake-head:
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

azande wrote: :rofl: :shake-head:
Well we can all have our opinions. If you're confident that you know better, so be it.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
mikeyr
Senior Member
Posts: 507
Joined: Thu Jan 22, 2004 11:00 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by mikeyr »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:You might or might not approve of the strategy, and the inevitable civilian deaths it is causing. But this is not mindless targetting of random buildings and vehicles in the middle of a city.
I agree, the IDF need to dismantle the Hezbollah command & control ability, in order to stand any chance of keeping this from descending into a war of attrition.

It is always sad that innocents are caught in the middle of a conflict, in this situation they are basically being used as human shields in the hope of bringing external political pressure(UN, G8 etc) to bear. Such is
asymetrical warfare. What would you do if you were in command?

Direct indescriminate bombing/shelling of population centres where there is little or no military presence is and always has been (from the allied blanket bombing in WWII onwards ) IMHO criminal.
User avatar
Baruch
Senior Member
Posts: 2261
Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2004 1:54 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Baruch »

mikeyr wrote:Such is
asymetrical warfare. What would you do if you were in command?
If I were in command I wouldn't be stupid enough to provoke Israel into attacking me in the first place.
To err is human, to moo bovine.
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:If Israel wanted to "bomb the shit out of the capital city" - you can bet that's what they'd be doing. As it is, what I think you're watching is a large collection of surgical strikes against targets in all sorts of areas where intelligence suggests Hezbollah arms and personnel are stored.
Surgical strikes?? Think you need to either find a dictionary or understand military tactics better. Surgical strikes do not result in the deaths of hundreds of innocent civilians and cause huge amounts of infrastructure damage to a country that is NOT AT WAR.

After following the debate from a distance it seems that the original point I have tried to make has been missed. REGARDLESS OF PROVOCATION any Nation that wishes to be seen as civilised has to follow certain humanitarian rules .... and attacking non-combatants in the hope that some of them may be bad guys is NOT civilised.

A certain forumites felt entitled to neg-rep me (and they are totally entitled to do so) because of my parody of the UK using a similar justification to Israel to nuke Eire. However, the justification of "You're trivialising and playing the fool over something way bigger than you" I felt was sanctimonious, condescending and fundamentally flawed. The situation, at its heart, IS very simple.
  1. Innocent people are being killed in large numbers
  2. The enemy’s offensive capability is not being seriously diminished
  3. For every Hezbollah soldier killed, several more will take their place (quote from the ex-Head of Mossad).
In case you think I'm playing the fool, the US has experienced this in Vietnam and Iraq, Russia has also come foul of this. even the good old UK found that the 'Irish Troubles' could only be solved by diplomacy not by force. So, what makes you think Israel can bomb its opponents into agreement? .... or am I being too simple again? :flower:
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

Gus wrote: After following the debate from a distance it seems that the original point I have tried to make has been missed. REGARDLESS OF PROVOCATION any Nation that wishes to be seen as civilised has to follow certain humanitarian rules .... and attacking non-combatants in the hope that some of them may be bad guys is NOT civilised.
Agreed, but are you talking about Lebanon or Israel?
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Gus wrote:A certain forumites felt entitled to neg-rep me (and they are totally entitled to do so) because of my parody of the UK using a similar justification to Israel to nuke Eire. However, the justification of "You're trivialising and playing the fool over something way bigger than you" I felt was sanctimonious, condescending and fundamentally flawed.
No need to be shy about it - it was I, and I think my rep comment was pretty much on the mark. Your latest attempt to demonstrate that you understand this subject (you fail) is at least respectful to the seriousness of the subject so it deserves a longer reply.
the US has experienced this in Vietnam and Iraq, Russia has also come foul of this. even the good old UK found that the 'Irish Troubles' could only be solved by diplomacy not by force. So, what makes you think Israel can bomb its opponents into agreement
Hmmm.... "agreement". Well, let's see. Among the dozens of differences between the situation in the Middle East and your cliché analogies of Ireland, Vietnam etc is this significant one: The goal of the IRA was to drive the British from Ireland, not to drive the British from Britain. The Americans in Vietnam were not fighting a foe who wished to deny America its very existence. No-one in Chechenya had designs on replace Russia with an Islamic state.

Rightly or wrongly (and regretfully I must accept some reading this thread will have a spectrum of opinions on that point) Israel's enemies have a goal to destroy that state in it's entirety. Israel has a contradictory goal: acceptance as a sovereign Jewish state by it's neighbours. You can never use force to make your neighbours love you - which is no great shakes, really, as being loved is clearly way off Israel's agenda. But you can, perhaps, use force to make your neighbours understand that you're there to stay.
Gus wrote:Am I being too simple again?
Yes.

Let's look at it another way: If the solution is as easy as you say (negotiation) then ask why no-one in the Israeli Government (or Hizbullah for that matter) is taking that option. That could be because:

1. They're too stupid to think of it
2. They're all evil and they just enjoy killing people
3. Your analysis is wrong

I don't believe 2, even if it is printed daily in the Independent. I don't believe 1 either (no offence, Gus, but if even you thought of it...) So that leaves 3.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
Lani
Junior Member
Posts: 2
Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 1:19 am

Re: Hezbollah Caught Offside

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lani »

Will wrote:For me, the blood in this conflict falls squarly on the hands of Hezbollah (and probably Syria and Iran for supporting them). The idea that there is a moral equivalence between the 2 sides is clearly wrong (i.e. saying that they're all as bad as each other) despite what the left-wing British press might want us to believe.
Hear, Hear.

Iran and Syria, need to wake up to themselves and realise that they have bigger internal issues to deal with (in terms of health care, womens rights, justice) than Israel and that their citizens would benefit more from this than another prolonged draw out battle.

Lani
User avatar
Msfab
Senior Member
Posts: 1104
Joined: Tue Feb 22, 2005 2:32 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Msfab »

Hope this helps - an unbaised view (if one exists:rolleyes :)
http://www.mideastweb.org/briefhistory.htm
Ditch the diplomacy, let’s dance!

Smile...It confuses people (Sandi Thom):D
Post Reply