Israel v Lebanon

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
Post Reply
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Barry Shnikov wrote:In the same way that the specific term 'decimate' is often employed meaning 'to destroy large numbers of' rather than the more proper 'to destroy 10% of'.
Well, yes, but answer the question, would you? What what did you mean by disenfranchise, when you used the word? I still don't know, which is why I'm asking again.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
jiveknight
Senior Member
Posts: 247
Joined: Wed Oct 12, 2005 12:28 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by jiveknight »

Feelingpink wrote:I never understand how people come to the conclusion that "the media ... have their story 'written'" on this or any other issue. The media is a number of news professionals & organisations & columnists. Sure, there are cases when one outlet will report something and others assume this to be 'true' without checking it out themselves. That's not great. But given that there are different news organisation owners, independent journalists and columnists (who love to give a dissenting view) from different countries, I just don't understand that there could possibly be a pre-ordained line for them all to follow, which they all would. Perhaps, JiveKnight, you could explain this? I do believe, however, that as individuals, it is good to get our news from different sources so that we can make up our own minds on different subjects.
I have worked with many different media personally and have found this to be true in many cases in my experience, though not on such a huge scale, but certain things do go in and certain things get left out. Maybe not "pre-ordained" but certainly it does happen and often to a certain slant. The exceptions being where that slant hasn't been "pre-ordained" by some vested interest. Obviously my opinion from my experience, but look yourself a deeper nad see what you find.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:My question is: why is none of this reported in the mainstream media? Is it too "detailed"? Does it not match the "story" that the media likes to build for its audience? I really don't know.
The question that immediately sprang to my mind was "is it true and unbiased?", and I'm surprised that nobody else has felt the same way. Historically, chain emails have proven to be highly unreliable on all subjects. Snopes is littered with examples of people making up random junk for their own purposes and spreading it through the relative anonymity of chain emails. It's an excellent way of spreading propaganda without the risk of being held accountable for your lies and bias by the propagandists on the other side.

The material in this chain email is sourced, in part, from here:
http://www.un.org/Depts/dpko/missions/u ... lpress.htm

So why did the propagandist not link to his source? Probably because it doesn't match the picture he's trying to paint.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:So why did the propagandist not link to his source? Probably because it doesn't match the picture he's trying to paint.
It's interesting that when the BBC choose which parts of a UN report to repeat, that's journalism - but when it's someone else it becomes propaganda.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:The question that immediately sprang to my mind was "is it true and unbiased?"
That's the point I'm trying to make. By ignoring the fire against the UN from Hizbullah, the mainstream media gives a false impression of Israel (alone) targetting the UN positions. The contents of the email that I quoted are all in the webpage you link to (thanks for that) so I'm not sure how you can classify it as propaganda. Not, at any rate, if you can in all consicence label the mainstream media's determination to ignore these subtle 'difficulties' with the way they like to portray 'the story' as responsible journalism.
Martin Harper wrote:Snopes is littered with examples of people making up random junk for their own purposes and spreading it through the relative anonymity of chain emails. It's an excellent way of spreading propaganda without the risk of being held accountable for your lies and bias by the propagandists on the other side.
That may be true, but it was not a chain email that I recieved, and I know the author personally.
Martin Harper wrote: So why did the propagandist not link to his source? Probably because it doesn't match the picture he's trying to paint.
Out of interest, when was the last time you saw the BBC or the Guardian link to a UN report they were (equally selectively) quoting from?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Cruella
Senior Member
Posts: 6159
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2004 11:00 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Cruella »

'Judah and Mohammad' Channel 4 tonight at 8.00pm. A programme about two teenage boys, one Israeli and one Palestinian living amongst this conflict. Could make interesting viewing for some of you involved in this thread.
Life isn't about waiting for the storm to pass... but instead learning to dance in the rain.
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

MartinHarper wrote:The question that immediately sprang to my mind was "is it true and unbiased?", and I'm surprised that nobody else has felt the same way.
I'm even more surprised you can magically tell nobody else has felt the same way]Historically, chain emails have proven to be highly unreliable on all subjects. Snopes is littered with examples of people making up random junk for their own purposes and spreading it through the relative anonymity of chain emails.[/quote]True. However in this case the quotes given were actually excerpts from the UNIFIL reports; yes they are selective quotes, but in the context I don't think that invalidates them. (If someone complains "how come this side of the story isn't reported", it is unsurprising that they provide a one-sided account).
So why did the propagandist not link to his source? Probably because it doesn't match the picture he's trying to paint.
Or maybe he thought it more unbiased to let people research the source themselves. By your own argument, any link provided in such an email would be suspect; I know I'm much more likely to trust a website I found using google.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:True. However in this case the quotes given were actually excerpts from the UNIFIL reports]this[/B] side of the story isn't reported", it is unsurprising that they provide a one-sided account).
OK, I see the misunderstanding, Martin. That email that I quoted (which quoted the UNIFIL reports) wasn't supposed to be a true and fair summary of the entire situation - it was just drawing attention to a few omissions from 'the story' as presented by major news outlets. Sure, it's 'propaganda' if you take it to be something that it isn't, but it was only supposed to fill in a few gaps - or, as David rightly says, be a whinge about "how come this isn't reported?"
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:It was not a chain email that I recieved, and I know the author personally.
Interesting. You see, I think this material originated from "Smooth Stone", which I would describe as yet another propaganda site focusing on conflicts in and around Israel. You can view it here:

http://smoothstone.blogspot.com/2006/07 ... nifil.html

Who do you think the material originated from? Is it the same person?
El Salsero Gringo wrote:That email that I quoted ... wasn't supposed to be a true and fair summary of the entire situation ... it was just drawing attention to a few omissions from 'the story' as presented by major news outlets
There will always be omissions in any news story about anything, controversial or not. There are space limitations, and readers do not have unlimited interest. This is convenient for propagandists. Pro-Israeli propagandists emphasise omissions that would make the reader sympathise more with the Israelis, and attempt to portray the mass media as anti-Israeli. Anti-Israeli propagandists emphasise omissions that would make the reader sympathise more with non-Israelis, and attempt to portray the mass media as pro-Israeli. It's an old game, and there are plenty of omissions for both sides to play with.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:On this forum I don't want to discuss things with anonymous columnists who aren't going to be able to back up their opinions.
Given this comment of yours to Ash, I can't believe you reposted propaganda for an anonymous columnist deliberately. What's the deal?
David Franklin wrote:I'm even more surprised you can magically tell nobody else has felt the same way]

My apologies, David. I did read that post of yours, but I only skimmed the first paragraph, so I didn't see you expressing a very similar point to the one I later made. In any case, as you point out, I can't tell what people are thinking and feeling: only what they write.
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

MartinHarper wrote:BLAH BLAH BLAH
There will always be omissions in any news story about anything, controversial or not. There are space limitations, and readers do not have unlimited interest.


zzzzzzzzzz

;)
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:There will always be omissions in any news story about anything, controversial or not. There are space limitations, and readers do not have unlimited interest. This is convenient for propagandists.
It's more convenient for the news media: "oh, yes, sorry we missed out that salient fact, but there wasn't time or space. We can't print everything you know!"
Martin Harper wrote: Pro-Israeli propagandists emphasise omissions that would make the reader sympathise more with the Israelis, and attempt to portray the mass media as anti-Israeli. Anti-Israeli propagandists emphasise omissions that would make the reader sympathise more with non-Israelis, and attempt to portray the mass media as pro-Israeli. It's an old game, and there are plenty of omissions for both sides to play with.
Martin, if your a priori position is that the media is unbiased (is that a law of your universe, or are you prepared to think about that assumption? In either direction?) then naturally anyone who disagrees with you is a 'propagandist'. On the other hand, if one feels that the media is not straightforward, what then? I don't see that your apparently even-handed condemnation of both sides encourages anyone to do anything except shut their eyes to the issue of what gets reported and what doesn't - exactly the opposite of what I think people should be encouraged to do.
MartinHarper wrote:Given this comment of yours to Ash, I can't believe you reposted propaganda for an anonymous columnist deliberately. What's the deal?
I think we've established that it's not propaganda, unless you happen to write leaders for the Guardian or the Independent in which case many inconvenient facts can be dismissed thus. Anyway you've missed the point of my objection to what Ash posted. If he wants to post specific information he believes to be factual - regardless of the source - I'd like to read it and agree with it, rebut it, or let it pass without comment. If he'd like to explain a line of argument in this thread on the forum then, likewise. But linking to a webpage without comment of his own (which I didn't do) means that no-one can engage him on the subject. And if, instead, he wants to adopt as his own opinion the entirety of someone else's Internet column without any kind of interpretation or critical analysis of his own then how interesting is that?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

One sub-plot of this thread is who you believe and why. One theory is that we tend to believe those that tell us we are right or otherwise assist our interests. It now occurs to me that I believed my source on "Dresden" because I knew he was qualified, experienced and valued truth above his own personal interests.
I was "learning the trade", with no training, from the bottom as tea-boy and numbers clerk, and came to a vastly different conclusion from that of my bosses with over 100 years of experience, all with degrees, and two higher degrees. Basically I tried to persuade them that their 6 months work was
substantially junk. Gordon told me how I could prove my contention, and I did.
40 years later I now realise that I accepted his word because of his experience and intellect, integrity and open-mindness on one matter, Dresden, whilst proving that his experience and intellect, along with the rest of the team, were wrong on the project. It appears that I am still learning.
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

El Salsero Gringo wrote: My contention is, and has been (for the last two dozen posts) that the mainstream media does a poor job (and from my point of view a very partisan job) of including background material - the 'small' facts - along with the big ones. My contention is that this is done not because of an orchestrated conspiracy but because the mainstream media line is hard to buck. Facts get selected and trimmed according to how well they build the picture that already exists in the collective minds of the journalists, and there's overwhelming peer pressure to toe that line.
Some more facts re what is happening in Northern Israel :sad:

-----------------------

Northern Israel under barrage

In Israel, the death toll is 39 -- 17 of them civilians and 22 soldiers -- according to the IDF. More than 300 civilians and more than 60 soldiers have been wounded.

The latest barrage of Hezbollah rockets landed near the northern Israeli cities of Tiberias, Kiryat Shmona, Maalot, Nahariya and north of Haifa.

By Monday afternoon, 90 rockets had been fired at northern Israel, wounding seven people, Israeli police said.

-----------------------
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:"oh, yes, sorry we missed out that salient fact, but there wasn't time or space. We can't print everything you know!"
The media misses out facts that are convenient for pro-Israelis. It also misses out facts that are convenient for anti-Israelis. The propagandists ask for the media to do the impossible. The existence of unreported facts is not evidence for the media being biased. My periodic exhalation of carbon dioxide is not evidence that I'm in favour of global warming.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:Martin, if your a priori position is that the media is unbiased....
It isn't. The media is controlled by various people, all of whom have their own biases, and also has a systematic bias towards stories that sell well. However, it's a heck of a lot less biased that the anonymous and self-confessed "fan of disproportionate response" that is Mr. Smooth Stone. Bluntly, I'd rather get my information from someone who's not a member of the War Crimes Appreciation Society.

I'm still confused as to how this guy's blog managed to end up in your inbox. Perhaps you could explain?
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:The media is controlled by various people, all of whom have their own biases, and also has a systematic bias towards stories that sell well. However, it's a heck of a lot less biased that the anonymous and self-confessed "fan of disproportionate response" that is Mr. Smooth Stone. Bluntly, I'd rather get my information from someone who's not a member of the War Crimes Appreciation Society.
I read his opinions with a wide amount of skepticism too, but it doesn't diminish the truth of that particular point: that there had been fire at the UN from both sides and that Hizbollah rockets were being launched from under the noses of the UN observers. That does rather put into some kind of context how it comes about that Israel dropped a bomb directly on a UN post and killed four unarmed solders. If you don't think it's relevant, then we must agree to disagree.

To put it as bluntly as possible: if I were the Israeli field commander who was receiving warnings from the UN solders saying that my shelling was endangering their safety, my response could well be "Well, see those guys outside your window with the yellow flags and the rockets? They're endangering my safety. If you want safety, go somewhere else. Meanwhile I'm going to continue my fire at the guy who's trying to kill me. If you get hit in the process, sorry but that's tough luck on you."

We both have to remember that just because some information comes from a biased source, doesn't automatically make it false, or wrong to consider it.
Martin Harper wrote:I'm still confused as to how this guy's blog managed to end up in your inbox. Perhaps you could explain?
No mystery. It was sent to me, by someone I know. Did he source it? No. Does that invalidate its contents (which as I've said, in my judgement contains not propaganda but verifiable and directly relevant background material)? No. Was it a random "chain" of unverifiable contents and unknowable provenance? No. It was my judgement that the contents were relevant and interesting in the context of this thread. I wasn't putting them up as anyone else's opinion. If you think otherwise, call me on it, not Mr. Smooth Stone, or the person that sent me the email.

By the way, if there's material that goes towards explaining the Hizbullah actions - putting them in some kind of context, I wish the media would give more time to that too. I note (you mentioned it too) that the debate appears to be between one side villifying Israeli actions, and the other side trying to make out that Israel is saint, there's very little by comparison about Hizbullah.

It's very easy to cast the actions of either side as mad, evil, incomprehensible, contemptible etc. I can read about how that applies to Israel in, for instance, the Guardian, and I can read about how it applies to any of the other groups in, for instance, various websites. BUT - I'd rather read how both sides are are reacting in the way they believe to be wisest. If that means including background material like the stuff I mentioned, about both sides, then I think that would be good.

It's very easy, as I said, to lambast, and to polarise. But I don't think it's very helpful to any kind of resolution.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:To put it as bluntly as possible: if I were the Israeli field commander who was receiving warnings from the UN solders saying that my shelling was endangering their safety, my response could well be "Well, see those guys outside your window with the yellow flags and the rockets? They're endangering my safety. If you want safety, go somewhere else. Meanwhile I'm going to continue my fire at the guy who's trying to kill me. If you get hit in the process, sorry but that's tough luck on you."
Of course, hypothetically the UN response might be "You know, the biggest danger to my safety is the Israeli forces. Maybe I need to start firing at them. If they want safety, they can go somewhere else."

I accept with asymmetric warfare and low intensity conflict, there is always going to be a tension between targetting insurgents and avoiding civilian casualties. In an imperfect world, innocents are always going to be amongst the dead. But the current Israeli attacks do seem particulalry poorly aimed, and I'm unaware of any justification for bombing of Lebanese power stations, for example.
We both have to remember that just because some information comes from a biased source, doesn't automatically make it false, or wrong to consider it.
Agreed.
No mystery. It was sent to me, by someone I know. Did he source it? No.
It may not have been your intent, but when you posted:
ESG wrote:It was not a chain email that I recieved, and I know the author personally.
I certainly understood you to mean that the information you recieved was the work of the author you knew personally. If he didn't tell you it was cut and pasted from elsewhere, it doesn't speak well of him; if he did but you neglected to say that here, then I'm sorry but it doesn't speak well of you. I must say that when Martin posted the link showing the quotes actually came from a website, I felt I had been mislead.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Hizbollah rockets were being launched from under the noses of the UN observers. ... "Well, see those guys outside your window with the yellow flags and the rockets?" ... etc.
My reading of the UNIFIL reports does not support that viewpoint. It seems there was no reported firing on Israeli positions by Hezbullah from around the UN Khayim post that day, or the previous day. UNIFIL have reported other instances of firing, but not from there. Feel free to check for yourself, though. It is possible that my skim-reading or lack of local geographical knowledge has caused me to overlook such a piece of evidence.
http://www.un.org/Depts/dpko/missions/u ... lpress.htm

Of course, that's not the impression you get from reading chain email propaganda. Deliberate distortion with occasional elements of truth: much more effective that pure lies.
El Salsero Gringo wrote:It was sent to me, by someone I know. Did he source it? No.
Sloppy journalism from someone complaining about sloppy journalism.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:My reading of the UNIFIL reports does not support that viewpoint. It seems there was no reported firing on Israeli positions by Hezbullah from around the UN Khayim post that day, or the previous day. UNIFIL have reported other instances of firing, but not from there. Feel free to check for yourself, though. It is possible that my skim-reading or lack of local geographical knowledge has caused me to overlook such a piece of evidence.
http://www.un.org/Depts/dpko/missions/unifil/unifilpress.htm
Indeed. Does that invalidate the background fact that Hizbullah are reported to have been firing from adjacent to UN positions?

Nothing in what I quoted nor my hastily written quasi-summary ("Four UN soliders were killed by an Israeli bomb]don't [/B]feel that what the UNIFIL reports contained was in any way relevant to an understanding of how Israel came to be dropping bombs on a UN base then make no bones about it and say so. You will presumably be in good company, along with the BBC and other august bodies who failed to refer to it. To my mind, however, it is relevant.
Martin Harper wrote:Sloppy journalism from someone complaining about sloppy journalism.
Accepted. Mea culpa.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:I accept with asymmetric warfare and low intensity conflict, there is always going to be a tension between targetting insurgents and avoiding civilian casualties. In an imperfect world, innocents are always going to be amongst the dead. But the current Israeli attacks do seem particulalry poorly aimed, and I'm unaware of any justification for bombing of Lebanese power stations, for example.
Are you sufficiently confident that no such justification could exist? Would you be interested to know what was in the mind of the person who decided to target the power stations was? Would that make any difference to you? Speaking for myself, I want to know what's in the mind of the main firing the rockets raining down on Israeli towns, and I want to know that much more fervently than I'm interested in condemning him.
David Franklin wrote:It may not have been your intent, but when you posted ...
You are right, and I should not have jumped to argue about where I heard the information about the UN. My apologies to you and Martin for that.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:There was a good reason to suppose that there was a Hizbullah presence located in the vicinity
What was the good reason?
El Salsero Gringo wrote:So, if you don't feel that what the UNIFIL reports contained was in any way relevant to an understanding of how Israel came to be dropping bombs on a UN base then make no bones about it and say so.
It's certainly relevant background information. Also relevant are the other incidents in the last few weeks where UNIFIL people have died or been injured due to Israeli military action. The BBC news article on the Khayim incident didn't include either of these pieces of background information. What information would you like them to remove in order to make room for these important pieces of background information?
Post Reply