Israel v Lebanon

Talk about anything not related to dancing...
Have fun, it's your Forum!
Post Reply
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Are you sufficiently confident that no such justification could exist?
Strawman, I believe. Obviously such justification could exist. What I am confident about is that I have heard no such justification.
Would you be interested to know what was in the mind of the person who decided to target the power stations was?
Certainly I'd love to hear an explanation. Because to my naive eyes, it appears to be a particularly counterproductive action. After all the military action so far, Hezbullah seems stronger than ever. And I suspect they will have gained a whole new generation of recruits from this.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

David Franklin wrote:I suspect they will have gained a whole new generation of recruits from this.
Like this?

http://www.newsgaming.com/games/index12.htm
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:What was the good reason?
OK. More research. Let me direct you to this page:

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060718/mideast_lebanon_UN_060716/20060719/

and paragraph (4) of Major Paeta Hess-von Kruedener's report where ihe states:

"Team Sierra is currently observing both IDF/IAF and Hezbollah military clashes from our vantage point which has a commanding view of ... most of the Hezbollah static positions in and around our patrol Base."

I will leave you to verify that my elipsis has omitted nothing that diminishes the signficance of one of the UN soldiers who was himself killed on July 26 referring to the existence of Hizbullah positions inside the UN compound.
Martin Harper wrote: It's certainly relevant background information. Also relevant are the other incidents in the last few weeks where UNIFIL people have died or been injured due to Israeli military action. The BBC news article on the Khayim incident didn't include either of these pieces of background information. What information would you like them to remove in order to make room for these important pieces of background information?
I'd like them to remove whatever information they need to have space to give a fairer background to the actions and reactions of both sides. I don't think that's too much to expect from a professional journalist (not something I claim to be.) I totally reject the idea that it's impossible to give balanced background "because there's not room."
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:OK. More research. Let me direct you to this page:
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20060718/mideast_lebanon_UN_060716/20060719/
My name is Major Paeta Hess-von Kruedener, and I ... am currently serving as an unarmed Military Observer.
Unarmed? :what:

Big brass ones, that's what he's got - going around, in that area, in a uniform, and without a gun. :respect:

As for the power-station bombing:
David Franklin wrote:Strawman, I believe. Obviously such justification could exist. What I am confident about is that I have heard no such justification.
The justification is that infrastructure attacks weaken the enemy's coordination and communications functions. It makes sense if you assume that Hizbullah = Lebanon, as it's the sort of standard military tactics you'd use against a state, "softening them up", as it's so quaintly put.

Of course, if you assume Hizbullah <> Lebanon, then it's a grossly disproportionate and unfair victimisation of a people, many of whom who are trying to establish a workable democracy in an area not exactly known for its democratic traditions.

Like all these things, it depends on your point of view.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:Strawman, I believe. Obviously such justification could exist. What I am confident about is that I have heard no such justification.
I haven't either. But until I started to look, I hadn't heard a justification for why Israel might be dropping munitions on UN posts. If one is not open to the existence of an explanation, one is unlikely ever to see one, still less to decide whether one thinks it has any merit.

David, I don't want to fight you (or Martin) over the meaning of words - especially not in this thread. I'm making my point as well as I can (imperfectly) but compared to "which foot do you step back on" threads, this one is more serious in content. I understand all the points that you make. I hope you understand mine. If we disagree on a few things (probably less than it sounds, since I haven't wasted any words claiming that all Israeli actions are beyond doubt the wisest possible) then ... we disagree. Nothing more earth shattering than that.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

DavidJames wrote:The justification is that infrastructure attacks weaken the enemy's coordination and communications functions. It makes sense if you assume that Hizbullah = Lebanon, as it's the sort of standard military tactics you'd use against a state, "softening them up", as it's so quaintly put.
I'd heard that justification with respect to the Palestians and Hamas, but not with Lebanon. (And all the quotes I've heard from Israeli officials do seem to be distinguishing between Lebannon and Hizbullah).

I think a key question here is how indiscriminate the use of force can be before it becomes immoral? How many innocents should suffer to stop one terrorist? And the answer to that depends on many things, most especially the abilities and vulnerabilities of the state and the perceived level of threat. If you genuinely think all the countries surrounding you would like to see you wiped off the face of the map, an attitude of "better 1000 of them die, than one of us" is probably understandable. But I think it's very hard to keep that attitude from becoming "the rights of other 'tribes' don't count". And Israel should understand better than anyone where that can lead.

To ESG on strawmen: I think my point is that until you hear an actual explanation, you can't possibly judge. Though to be honest it would have to be a bloody good one. If there was a secret nuclear weapons program that had to be stopped, fair enough. If it was "if we make life miserable for everyone in Lebanon it's bound to affect a few terrorists" I'm much less convinced. In the absence of other knowledge, I'm inclined to think the true reason is closer to the latter scenario.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

David Franklin wrote:To ESG on strawmen: ... In the absence of other knowledge, I'm inclined to think the true reason is closer to the latter scenario.
If that's how you're inclined, who am I to say otherwise?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

David Franklin wrote: . If there was a secret nuclear weapons program that had to be stopped, fair enough.
Hizbullah probably with Iran funding about 7yrs away from nuclear weapon of some sort. Before this started say 55 yrs ?
Gus
Senior Member
Posts: 5203
Joined: Mon Mar 04, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gus »

David Franklin wrote:I think a key question here is how indiscriminate the use of force can be before it becomes immoral? How many innocents should suffer to stop one terrorist? And the answer to that depends on many things, most especially the abilities and vulnerabilities of the state and the perceived level of threat. If you genuinely think all the countries surrounding you would like to see you wiped off the face of the map, an attitude of "better 1000 of them die, than one of us" is probably understandable. But I think it's very hard to keep that attitude from becoming "the rights of other 'tribes' don't count". And Israel should understand better than anyone where that can lead.
And that, in a nutshell, is the central question of the thread that ESG has categorically refused to answer. :whistle:
"We all believe in something... greater than ourselves, even if it's just the blind forces of chance" - G'Kar.
User avatar
stewart38
Senior Member
Posts: 7480
Joined: Fri May 09, 2003 8:56 am

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by stewart38 »

David Franklin wrote: I think a key question here is how indiscriminate the use of force can be before it becomes immoral? How many innocents should suffer to stop one terrorist? And the answer to that depends on many things, most especially the abilities and vulnerabilities of the state and the perceived level of threat. If you genuinely think all the countries surrounding you would like to see you wiped off the face of the map, an attitude of "better 1000 of them die, than one of us" is probably understandable. But I think it's very hard to keep that attitude from becoming "the rights of other 'tribes' don't count". And Israel should understand better than anyone where that can lead.
There hasnt been a country on this planet that hasnt been immoral
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

Gus wrote:And that, in a nutshell, is the central question of the thread that ESG has categorically refused to answer. :whistle:
You haven't taken the trouble to ask, up to now.

But, if it were my life at stake, there are virtually no lengths I would not go to ensure my own survival. Seeing as my life isn't at stake, I don't feel empowered to sit in judgement on the actions of people for whom it is. I'll leave that to the moral experts such as you, Gus.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
bigdjiver
Senior Member
Posts: 4899
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 1:38 am
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by bigdjiver »

stewart38 wrote:There hasnt been a country on this planet that hasnt been immoral
You don't see a lot of Nethanderals about.
MartinHarper
Senior Member
Posts: 4157
Joined: Mon Jul 12, 2004 4:24 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by MartinHarper »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:I'd like them to remove whatever information they need to have space to give a fairer background to the actions and reactions of both sides.
I don't see any information in the BBC's article that they could remove without propagandists of one side or the other (or both) criticising them for selective reporting. Do you?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/5215366.stm
El Salsero Gringo wrote:Seeing as my life isn't at stake, I don't feel empowered to sit in judgement on the actions of people for whom it is.
Members of Hezbullah are vastly more likely than me to die or be serious wounded in some form of military action, yet I don't feel that prevents me from forming an opinion about the morality of Hezbullah's actions.
David Franklin wrote:all the quotes I've heard from Israeli officials do seem to be distinguishing between Lebannon and Hizbullah
How about this one from Israeli Justice Minister Haim Ramon?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/5219360.stm
BBC wrote:He added that Israel had given the civilians of southern Lebanon ample time to quit the area and therefore anyone still remaining there could be considered a Hezbollah supporter. "All those now in south Lebanon are terrorists who are related in some way to Hezbollah," Mr Ramon said.
Barry Shnikov
Senior Member
Posts: 6709
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2003 7:55 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Barry Shnikov »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:Like I said before, the IRA's aim was to get the British out of Ireland. Not to get the British out of Britain.
That's irrelevant. The statement you made was 'what was Israel supposed to negotiate with', and Britain was no more able to offer what the IRA sought to achieve than Israel.

You have to play with the hand you are dealt. If (and when, 'cos it should be remembered that it has done so) Israel chooses to negotiate, there are issues to be discussed.
Let go of my hands and for God's sake STOP BOUNCING!
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

MartinHarper wrote:How about this one from Israeli Justice Minister Haim Ramon?
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/5219360.stm
You mean this?
Ramon wrote:All those now in south Lebanon are terrorists who are related in some way to Hezbollah,"
I think it's an appalling denial of reality, but I don't think it equates Lebanon and Hezbollah. In fact, by the two qualifiers ("those now in south Lebanon"), it still implicitly distinguishes between them. The point is that Israel hasn't quite said "anywhere in Lebanon is a fair target, because Lebanon is Hezbullah". But in that case bombing Lebanese power stations seems uncalled for, even from the Israeli point of view.
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

MartinHarper wrote:Members of Hezbullah are vastly more likely than me to die or be serious wounded in some form of military action, yet I don't feel that prevents me from forming an opinion about the morality of Hezbullah's actions.
You are clearly an innately more judgemental person than I.
Barry Shnikov wrote:You have to play with the hand you are dealt. If (and when, 'cos it should be remembered that it has done so) Israel chooses to negotiate, there are issues to be discussed.
What is the extent of the issues to be discussed with Hizbullah, in your opinion?
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
David Bailey
Senior Member
Posts: 17001
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Bailey »

El Salsero Gringo wrote:What is the extent of the issues to be discussed with Hizbullah, in your opinion?
I'll take this one...

It's a tricky one - Hezbollah (yep, a third spelling, this is the Wikipedia Way!) was originally a "Israelis out" resistance movement. But since the Israelis did get out in 2000, it's now morphed into a "Israel must be destroyed" organisation. Again on the Wikipedia thing:
Hezbollah views Israel as a whole as "an illegal usurper entity, which is based on falsehood, massacres, and illusions" , and follows a distinct version of Islamic Shia ideology developed by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, leader of the Islamic Revolution in Iran.
Which makes it, shall we say, challenging to see how Israel can negotiate with them; Israel can hardly offer its own destruction.

The ultimate answer to this is the establishment of a proper independent Palestinian state - that will take most of the wind out of the sails of the extremists, the perceived (and yes, the actual) injustices visited on the Palestinian people. As always, Palestine is the key - get that done, and everything else will (eventually) fall in place.

But in the short-term, I don't think there's really much Israel can offer Hezbollah, apart now from re-withdrawing of course. Whether any security gains from the military action outweigh the boost for Hezbollah prestige and the lessening of perceived Israeli moral superiority, that's another question.
Jivetango Godfather
"if your arguments are poorly constructed, they are often misinterperetated" - CJ
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

Im still reading this but dont have the time to address many of the points. Plus I dont understand some of the big words :)

Ive got a solution though - move the whole of Israel to the U.S. State of Nebraska and call it "New Israel". Then everyones happy.*


*assuming no one already lives in nebraska
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
User avatar
El Salsero Gringo
Senior Member
Posts: 4881
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:00 pm

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by El Salsero Gringo »

DavidJames wrote:The ultimate answer to this is the establishment of a proper independent Palestinian state - that will take most of the wind out of the sails of the extremists, the perceived (and yes, the actual) injustices visited on the Palestinian people. As always, Palestine is the key - get that done, and everything else will (eventually) fall in place.
That is an oft stated view, but it doesn't actually hold a lot of water. Hizbullah is not interested in Palestinian state per se, but in fact in an Islamic republic (like Iran, it's sponsor) over the whole of what is now Israel.

Whatever Israel does, as long as it exists in some form or other, there will always be sufficient people in the Arab world (and outside it) to support extremist groups like Hamas and Hezbullah.

The ultimate answer to this lies in the real and final acceptance across the arab world of the existence of a sovereign Jewish State in the Middle East. The plight of the Palestinians is, and has been for 60 years, used as an excuse to avoid having to face up to this fact.

As someone remarked: if the arabs put down their weapons tomorrow, the fighting will cease. If Israel puts down its weapons tomorrow, Israel will cease to exist.
We aim to reply to 9 out of 10 PMs within 24 hours. Occasionally your queries will take longer to respond to. In that case we will let you know when you can expect a full reply to your question. El Salsero Gringo is a responsible member of the Donkey Ombudsman Scheme and abides by its code of practice. Your house may be at risk. You may go up and down.
User avatar
Dreadful Scathe
Senior Member
Posts: 12530
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2002 12:00 pm
Contact:

Re: Israel v Lebanon

Report a concern about this post

Post by Dreadful Scathe »

El Salsero Gringo wrote: As someone remarked: if the arabs put down their weapons tomorrow, the fighting will cease. If Israel puts down its weapons tomorrow, Israel will cease to exist.
A good quote and I doubt even Gus would disagree with the sentiment ;)
"defiantly a pork soared" -fletch DS is talking as much sense as most people I've heard - batnurse
"This is a discussion forum, not some sort of hippy poetry-reading commune" - TAFKADJ
Post Reply