Originally posted by Gadget
what, apart from style, makes the dancer "advanced" as opposed to "intermediate"?
Style is everything you put into a dance that you don't need to. This can be things you do deliberately, or subconsciously. It can be things you do right, or wrong, or just as a consequence of something else you do.
For my way of thinking, becoming an advanced dancer means you have to understand everything you need to do, deciding how to do things you want to do to develop your style, and knowing the difference between the two.
What you need to do in Modern Jive centres around leading and following. But it also incudes understanding the timing of Modern Jive, and the structure of the music. You have to understand your partner, and their part in the dance. You have to know how to spin, or what to do when your partner is spinning. You have to anticipate what other dancers might do, and how to react to them.
What you
want to do is obviously down to the individual. What you
actually do might be completely different. The 'buddy' couple system that Gary talked about might be very revealing for this. But there is still plenty that can be taught. For example you might suggest to intermediate dancers to wiggle your hips. But you would teach how to do Cuban motion to an advanced class. Then you would leave it down to the individual to decide if they are going to incorporate it.
Other examples would be presentation skills - very important to a competitor, irrelevant to some purely social dancers, but worth learning anyway.
So I would say the difference between an intermediate dancer and an advanced dancer is knowledge. Knowledge is different to experience, although frequently they have gone hand-in-hand. (Much of the existing knowledge has developed from the experience of some dancers.) And knowledge doesn't mean knowing a lot of moves. The best thing is that knowledge can be taught - as long as the teacher knows what they are talking about! (The problem with knowledge is the more you know, the more you have to concentrate - otherwise you end up forgetting to do everything.)
And aerials don't count.
I would agree with this. Aerials aren't dancing. They are just a way of showing off. The same statement can apply to drops.
I really don't see any difference in the complexity of moves.
I do see a difference - the advanced dancers tend to do
less complicated moves. They get in the way of dancing.
The skills of lead/follow ... can {should} be able to be taught by any CTA {/MJ} teacher.
Some MJ teachers (including some Ceroc teachers) are very good at following. I can't comment from personal experience what they are like at leading, but I've heard plenty of good comments about some teachers.
However some female MJ teachers (again including some Ceroc teachers) are exceptionally hard to lead. Again I can't say anything directly about the leaders, but I've heard enough bad comments about several male teachers.
Even amongst the good dancers, many find it difficult to explain even some of the basic ideas. They might be able to do it, but they don't actually know what they do. Fortunately the number of teachers who know what they are doing, and can teach it, is slowly increasing.
Understanding leading & following isn't difficult. Mastering it is virtually impossible, because there is always something else to learn. Luckily you don't have to master it completely to be good enough to do it well. I once saw a demo by a professional ballroom couple. They were the 3-times world champions, and were just about to retire from doing cabarets after many years. He said "I've been doing Foxtrot for over 30 years, and my teacher says I have almost figured out how to lead it..."
One other thing - remember that Advanced classes aren't aimed at Advanced dancers. They are aimed at the top-end of intermediate dancers who want to get better within the world of Modern Jive. When there are more advanced dancers around, then maybe you can try to offer something for them.