Are Great Dancers born or made?

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
User avatar
TheTramp
Senior Member
Posts: 10672
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by TheTramp »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
Being born into it implies family thing, genetic, eg father a great ceroc teacher/dancer, take one of my many kids for example :tears:

or natural implies natural ability can feel rythme, can move body and has the all important sense of timing which required by any great sportsperson, dancer etc.

Maybe I'm being thick here :confused:
Ah. I see.

No. I don't believe that genetics do necessarily help (except in your kids of course Adam :wink: ). (Although, being exposed to the subject matter from a young age might well... ).

So, let's go with the 'natural' explanation then!

Steve
Fluent in sarcasm! :flower:
User avatar
cerocmetro
Senior Member
Posts: 518
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by cerocmetro »

Originally posted by Lory
This is sooooo difficult to answer but i'm going to try :waycool:

When most kids are little they go through phases of trying different things out, be it, football, swimming, tennis or Dance. Some have an inbuilt abuility, they just shine out! Its strange that when a kid is good at one thing, they tend to be good at several

Some have eye ball co-ordination, some have balance, some have it all!

The ones who have the natural abuilty, tend to be better and then they get encouraged, therefore enjoy it more, so practice more and so on and it spirals, so my answer is, probably most of the 'great' dancers have danced some other form of dance b4 but they were ALSO born with 'IT' :sad:


Great points Lory, if you are good at something you do it more etc etc etc.

Therefore you have to have a degree of natural ability to start with, then lots of hard work.

Tiger woods is a natural golfer, he has been naturally good since playing every day from 3 years old :what:

Adam
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

Originally posted by ChrisA
Born talent. Natural. Whatever.

I nominate Kate from Hipsters. (No, not that Kate).

Sheepy knows her better than I do, so I expect he'll comment. I had a couple of dances with her on Wednesday and she is awesome.

And only 19 I believe.

Chris


I've known Kate since she started as she's another great Brighton dancer. She did ballroom when she was younger and she was good from her first class. So, on the nature/nurture graph I place Kate towards the nurture end.

The question is, is there anyone out there who'd never done any other dance or sport that required coordination that has become a great dancer?

Kate is coming home from London in the Uni holidays and she'll be all mine, mine, MINE...

If I'm asked nicely I might bring her with me to Hipsters :devil: :wink:
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by cerocmetro
Tiger woods is a natural golfer, he has been naturally good since playing every day from 3 years old :what:
So your saying it's natural because he started young? Isn't that the same as learning, but learning at a time when the mind and body is most receptive? Some will have genetic dispositions that don't allow them to be naturals eg bow legs (no names!), there are also theories about how touch can develop ability of movement right from the first days after birth (and therapists that have treatments to correct problems - I've been thinking of going :tears: )

Interesting that Kate should be the first name mentioned here, before Nigel, Nina, Amir, Tas, Sean, Andy, Rena. (There I've named some, but by no means my complete list). ChrisA obviously has Kate on his mind :wink:

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
User avatar
Sheepman
Senior Member
Posts: 3687
Joined: Wed May 14, 2003 4:52 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Sheepman »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor
If I'm asked nicely I might bring her with me to Hipsters :devil: :wink:
Pretty please? (don't worry about next Tuesday 'cos I'm working on the bar), and Bookham (27th) and Beaconsfield (26th), please!
Oh but don't bother on the last 2 if I end up going skiing!

Did I say PLEASE! :wink:

Greg
With one hand the past moves us forward, with the other it holds us back.
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Originally posted by Sheepman
Interesting that Kate should be the first name mentioned here, before Nigel, Nina, Amir, Tas, Sean, Andy, Rena. (There I've named some, but by no means my complete list). ChrisA obviously has Kate on his mind :wink:
Sheepster :reallymad

Tas was also on my list - I'd guess she's a natural, but I don't know her background - nor the others', although they're all pretty amazing.
User avatar
Lory
Senior Member
Posts: 9918
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:00 am
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lory »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor

The question is, is there anyone out there who'd never done any other dance or sport that required coordination that has become a great dancer?


I doubt it!
MODERATOR AT YOUR SERVICE :)
"If you're going to do something tonight, that you know you'll be sorry for in the morning, plan a lie in." Lorraine :wink:
Mikey
Senior Member
Posts: 242
Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Mikey »

Originally posted by Lory
I doubt it!


Your wrong there lory....

I am 39 and only started dancing 11 years ago.. and from the age of 8 till 16 I stideied Kung Fu privately gaining 7 Blacl belts in 7 forms.. after that i was a British freestyle rollersakting champion for 2 years and after that I did Shotokan karate and gained 2nd Dan... No where had i ever done any dance till 11 years ago...

I believe my own balance, co-ordination and ability to spin as I do all stems from those sports in my past...

And if i am not mistaken, Mr Lampert also did Karate ? :cheers:
Mikey
Senior Member
Posts: 242
Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Mikey »

Originally posted by Mikey
Your wrong there lory....

I am 39 and only started dancing 11 years ago.. and from the age of 8 till 16 I stideied Kung Fu privately gaining 7 Blacl belts in 7 forms.. after that i was a British freestyle rollersakting champion for 2 years and after that I did Shotokan karate and gained 2nd Dan... No where had i ever done any dance till 11 years ago...

I believe my own balance, co-ordination and ability to spin as I do all stems from those sports in my past...

And if i am not mistaken, Mr Lampert also did Karate ? :cheers:


And NO I cannot type to save my life regardless of all that either..LOL
User avatar
Will
Senior Member
Posts: 1476
Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Will »

Originally posted by Mikey
And if i am not mistaken, Mr Lampert also did Karate ? :cheers:
Origammi to be precise...
Bill
Senior Member
Posts: 2161
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2002 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Bill »

Something similar was debated on another thread and I have to agree withthe view that most, if not all, really great dancers on te jive scene probably have natural ability but have become as good as they are through very hard work.

DavidB has indicated how much time he and Lily spend before competitions and he would also argue that he's not a 'natural' and has had to work to be as good as he is. He might be the exception that proves the rule. :D

Unfortunately, the vast majority of cerocers/ jivers will never have the time to be as good as they really could be because of work/family/ social commitments and I agree with Adam that most folk are happy to dance and have a social night out. Even most folk who compete know they won't win but do it for fun.

Teachers can make a difference but you can teach a 'natural' dancer how to break, how to perfect moves etc but if someone has no real ability or rhythm they can learn how it should be done but find it very difficult to hear the breaks in a song when freestyling.

I've seen and danced with some really lovely and very good dancers all over the country and would categorise many of the women as very good but the 'greats' would still be the likes of Lily, Nina, Viktor, Nigel etc...... And yes they all work very hard at dancing but I'd argue that they were already naturally gifted and so the hard work pays real dividends.

I could practice 20 hours a week and although I'd learn mvoes and polish my technique I'd never ever come close to men like Viktor, Nigel, Dan .......... I don't have the time, my partner lives over 100 miles away and I know I'd never reach that level. But at least we can all keep doing the best we can and having fun - still the most important part of dancing :cheers: :D
Bill
Mikey
Senior Member
Posts: 242
Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Mikey »

Originally posted by Lory
I doubt it!


Sorry Lory,

I misread your answer to the qoute By McTo...eerrmmm McGregor... My opolgies hun :kiss:
User avatar
Lory
Senior Member
Posts: 9918
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:00 am
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lory »

Originally posted by Mikey
Sorry Lory,

I misread your answer to the qoute By McTo...eerrmmm McGregor... My opolgies hun :kiss:


No problem :hug:
MODERATOR AT YOUR SERVICE :)
"If you're going to do something tonight, that you know you'll be sorry for in the morning, plan a lie in." Lorraine :wink:
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

Originally posted by Lory
I doubt it!


Ageed :hug:

I think all the truly great modern jivers have something of their other skill in what they do at modern jive. The most obvious example of this, to my mind, is Amir. Probably before the music has even started you've marked him out as a ballet dancer.

Lory, maybe you and I should start going to ballet - then I could, quite legitimately, wear tights, act camp and carry you on my shoulder :wink:
User avatar
Will
Senior Member
Posts: 1476
Joined: Thu Aug 22, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Will »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor
Ageed :hug:

I think all the truly great modern jivers have something of their other skill in what they do at modern jive. The most obvious example of this, to my mind, is Amir.

Very astute of you Andy. It is a little known fact that back in New Zealand, Amir was a Gurning champion! :what:

Will
User avatar
ChrisA
Senior Member
Posts: 3831
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by ChrisA »

Originally posted by Will
Very astute of you Andy. It is a little known fact that back in New Zealand, Amir was a Gurning champion! :what:
And is this DavidB in the British Gurning semi-final?


Image
Jon
Senior Member
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2002 3:29 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jon »

So does being a natural dancer make a difference whether your a man or a lady?

If your a lady you have to be able to follow the mans lead but for a guy who's never danced before he has to learn moves & learn how to lead. So how can he be a natural dancer from day one?. After he's learned this then prehaps his natural talent comes out and he becomes a dancer with the ability to lead anything and make it look good.


I read Adams post with great interest and it makes so much sense. Before dancing with anyone I think you can always tell how they will dance just by holding their hand.

I also think a natural dancer who would be in the top 5% at least, is someone who doesn't realise that they are a great dancer until other people start telling them they are.
It's only one dance. What's the Worst that could happen!
User avatar
Emma
Senior Member
Posts: 1606
Joined: Tue May 07, 2002 11:00 am

Report a concern about this post

Post by Emma »

When I was first at art college we were constantly told that sucess was a matter of 1% inspiration(or talent) and 99% perspiration.

It's all very well being talented but you have to *do* something with it. Certainly in the art world most of those who are successful have had to be incredibly persistant and pushy with their talent, constantly keeping themsleves in the spotlight and making new opportunities for themselves. I see no reason why the dance world would be any different (maybe it is? How?) certainly all of the big dance 'names' that I can think of in MJ (including Adam ;) ) have an unusual degree of self-confidence and clearly work extremely hard at what they do.

Um, I think what I meant there was that there's no point being a natural or being talented if you don't work at it. :nice:
It's only dancing - but I like it :)
User avatar
Lory
Senior Member
Posts: 9918
Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 11:00 am
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Lory »

Originally posted by Emma

Um, I think what I meant there was that there's no point being a natural or being talented if you don't work at it. :nice:

Oh yes, agreed!

Talent needs to be nurtured and there's no way anyone is born naturally 'knowing' the leads for certain moves but you'd never make a 'great' dancer out of someone who can't even clap in time to a piece of music for instance, no matter how much effort they put in!
MODERATOR AT YOUR SERVICE :)
"If you're going to do something tonight, that you know you'll be sorry for in the morning, plan a lie in." Lorraine :wink:
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

Originally posted by Emma
certainly all of the big dance 'names' that I can think of in MJ (including Adam ;) ) have an unusual degree of self-confidence and clearly work extremely hard at what they do.

I agree, but which came first? the chicken or the egg?
Is the self-confidence a bi-product of being great, or is it the self-confidence that leads them to become great?
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
Post Reply