Advanced lead/follow

Confused by the Accordion Comb Pull Crab?

Spinning gets you dizzy?
Would like some help with a tricky intermediate move? Ask here, and share your fave tips...
You need to be registered / logged in to read this forum
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Advanced lead/follow

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

Originally posted by spindr
begin lousyanalogy:
As a one-time juggler (now a rusty, not a crusty) the analogy I would use is -- imagine you are holding a ball in your palm, to lead the ball to fall you can just lower your hand. To get into the "neutral" position you drop your hand slightly, so that the ball is released. You can keep this neutral/free-fall position as long as your hand keeps dropping at the same rate as the ball. When you want to catch the ball again, stop dropping your hand -- or even raise it, to catch it.
:end lousyanalogy


So does the follower (there are no ladies or mens positions in dance, that would be sexist :wink: ) hold the balls at the same time as the leader, does just one person hold the balls, is the the leader or follower that controls the balls (particularly their height :tears: ), how many balls are there, and most crucilly and the crux of my question - do you hold your own balls or your partners? :sick: And, even more importantly, how tightly do you hold them? :tears:

:wink:
DavidB
Senior Member
Posts: 2263
Joined: Wed Feb 20, 2002 12:00 pm

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Advanced lead/follow

Report a concern about this post

Post by DavidB »

Originally posted by spindr
I am assuming that you have a lightish handhold, and that the lady's hand is cupped loosely over yours (and that loosely if the key part here).
{snip}
"neutral" point
{snip}
The lady can pick up on this, and realise that there's a slight offer to improvise.
{snip}
I prefer not to have a completely 'neutral' point when leading. I always aim to have at least some compression or leverage in the lead, even when I am not actively leading a move. My lead then becomes a combination of increasing & decreasing this connection, or switching it from compression to leverage and back again. I find that this gives me greater control, and a better awareness of what the lady is doing, and is likely to do next. You can also make the invitation to improvise (the "window of opportunity") as long as you want. And you can do it with any hand hold, not just a standard one.

When you have a completely neutral position, it gives the lady no idea of what is coming next. It also allows the lady less to improvise with, as she can't use the man.

However my approach also has its drawbacks. Many ladies will take any leverage or compression as a lead, and will assume you are just leading another step badly. You also have to slightly change the timing of the move immediately prior to this 'invitation' lead, to make it more obvious what you are trying to do.

David
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Tension between partners

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

I agree with David B. My resting state of leading 'nothing' requires a certain tension. For me that tension is usually a slight pressure gently pulling my partner in my direction. I hope my partner interprets any change in the direction I apply that tension as a lead. But the resting state for me is an isometric thing where the tension between the partners is equal and results in no actual movement at all.

Some time ago I heard the description of how to hold a foil in fencing - and this could equally be applied to the tension between me and my partner. I was told to hold my sword as if it were a live bird that I didn't want to escape - but not to hold it so tightly that I squashed it. I did one hear a jive teacher say that the tension between partners should be enough to hold a jam doughnut but not enough to squeeze the jam out!

This brings me on to the things that,for me, go wrong with the connection. Personally I find a very common perpetual bouncing or flicking of my partners hand interrupts the tension and makes leading the way I do difficult. Often I also find that a partner who bounces/flicks their hand also does other things I haven't led. The most common ones are a sort of skipping with the feet, regular breaking of their shoulder and a shoulder height wave with the free hand on every step back - there's plenty of variations on these themes too. And what do I do? I just go along with it, try to lead the way I normally do which sometimes jars my wrist, elbow or shoulder :tears: And I sometimes get a cold stare from my skippy partner who is patiently waiting for the track to finish so her dance with the guy who doesn't know how to bounce his hand to the beat can be over. The bit that worries me most is, watching dancers at most classes, I'm the odd one out. Is it me and the 5% that do what I do or is it all of the others? The regularity that I'm asked 'what kind of dancing are you doing' makes me think it could be me :tears:

Maybe I should eat the doughnut, let that small bird go and put my balls in my pockets :wink:
Graham
Senior Member
Posts: 1981
Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2002 1:39 pm

Re: Re: Re: Advanced lead/follow

Report a concern about this post

Post by Graham »

Originally posted by Gadget
No; I think I get what you're getting at, but I think that you've got it the wrong way round {or I have :innocent: }:
- If I stop leading, I expect the lady to take over. What I mean is that they get no signals from me - neither compression or tension.
- If I want the lady to stop or do nothing, then I lead them to a stationary position; enough tension/compression to oppose their movements, but not enough to lead them in the opposite direction.

The phrase "you want her to improvise you should lead that too" is self contradicting - improvisation cannot be led; you can hint at the direction you want the lady to take, but she is the one who is doing her own thang.
What I meant was that you should lead a stop. Once you've stopped the follower will (hopefully) realise that it's an opportunity to improvise and will do her own thang - obviously you're not leading what she actually does, just leading the "window". If you just stop leading then the follower has to decide if there actually is a lead which she's somehow not feeling, if you wanted to stop and just haven't lead it, or if you've momentarily lost the plot and normal service will be restored shortly.
Jon
Senior Member
Posts: 283
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2002 3:29 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Jon »

Yes but Graham when I lead pauses its amazing how many times the lady will ask what am I suposed to do now or even worse look at you strangely wondering why you've stopped.

I think this trouble is caused by ceroc saying its a male led dance, and everyone is conditioned to think like that. It shouldn't be it's just dancing. I was chatting to a friend last night about this and it's not about leading moves, it's about the interaction between you your partner and the music and doing what feels natural.
It's only one dance. What's the Worst that could happen!
Graham
Senior Member
Posts: 1981
Joined: Fri Mar 29, 2002 1:39 pm

Report a concern about this post

Post by Graham »

Originally posted by Jon
Yes but Graham when I lead pauses its amazing how many times the lady will ask what am I suposed to do now or even worse look at you strangely wondering why you've stopped.
Yes, that's normal - generally I don't lead a pause except with dancers who feel as if they're experienced, or who have previously grabbed the initiative, and if they have this baffled reaction I won't do it again (or at least not for a while!)
Originally posted by Jon
I think this trouble is caused by ceroc saying its a male led dance, and everyone is conditioned to think like that.
They say that because it is. Or at least it is a lead-follow dance, where normally the man takes the lead part and the woman takes the follow part. There are other dance styles which are not lead-follow, and the dynamics are very different from modern jive.
User avatar
Gadget
Senior Member
Posts: 7053
Joined: Wed Oct 09, 2002 9:08 pm
Contact:

Re: Tension between partners

Report a concern about this post

Post by Gadget »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor
Some time ago I heard the description of how to hold a foil in fencing...

OK, your versions are somewhat cleaner than I was taught :innocent: .
I have noticed more than once that there are remarkable similarities in the grip and guidance {even down to DavidB advocating the 'pistol' grip} of a lead and manipulating a weapon.
Originally posted by DavidB
When you have a completely neutral position, it gives the lady no idea of what is coming next. It also allows the lady less to improvise with, as she can't use the man.
Perhaps this is where I go wrong then? As with SpinDr, I tend to 'stop leading' from a move that has some momentum so that the lady's natural fall/flow of the hand could be taken as an invitation. Perhaps I am being too subtle?
If I want a lady to improvise from a 'stop'; then I will stop them, then remove the lead untill she gives me an indication of what she is doing, then try to give her something to work with: The 'invitation' is the removal of the lead.

I also take Jon's point that the lady can look puzzled and ask what to do - If the lady does not pick up on the 'gap', then I close it fairly quickly; if they then react with the "Dam; I missed it" expression, I will look for another opportunity in the music.
I used to be an angel, you know with halo and those wings;
Now that i'm a devil, my mind's on other things...
My feathers turned to ash, and my harp has broke in two;
I took uppon myself, to have a dance with you...
User avatar
Andy McGregor
Senior Member
Posts: 9276
Joined: Mon Mar 03, 2003 12:00 pm

Re: Re: Tension between partners

Report a concern about this post

Post by Andy McGregor »

Originally posted by Gadget
OK, your versions are somewhat cleaner than I was taught :innocent: .


:rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

I'd forgotten about that other method of describing how tightly to hold your weapon...
Originally posted by Gadget
I have noticed more than once that there are remarkable similarities in the grip and guidance {even down to DavidB advocating the 'pistol' grip} of a lead and manipulating a weapon.


That struck me immediately too.

For those of you that aren't fencers like Gadget and me there is a type of sword handle called a pistol grip and the hand shape you make when holding it is a tighter version of the one David B described. This is especially noticeable to people gifted with left-handedness :wink:

The similarities between martial arts and dancing keep surprising me. I think that the "Dancing as a demonstration of fighting skill" argument is supported by these similarities.

Although I'm not so sure about the argument that females of the species want to mate with good dancers/fighters is true in my case :tears:
User avatar
David Franklin
Senior Member
Posts: 3426
Joined: Fri Feb 22, 2002 1:52 pm

Re: Re: Re: Tension between partners

Report a concern about this post

Post by David Franklin »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor
Although I'm not so sure about the argument that females of the species want to mate with good dancers/fighters is true in my case :tears:
Hmm... Martial Arts, Marital Arts - typo or Freudian slip?

Dave
User avatar
spindr
Senior Member
Posts: 1617
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:41 am

Round spherical objects

Report a concern about this post

Post by spindr »

Originally posted by Andy McGregor
So does the follower (there are no ladies or mens positions in dance, that would be sexist :wink: ) hold the balls at the same time as the leader, does just one person hold the balls, is the the leader or follower that controls the balls (particularly their height :tears: ), how many balls are there, and most crucilly and the crux of my question - do you hold your own balls or your partners? :sick: And, even more importantly, how tightly do you hold them? :tears: :wink:


Round spherical objects! I should have known it was tempting providence :)

Although, now I think of it I guess it would count as advanced lead/follow -- if you're led by 'em you're sure to follow. But then again I think Ballroom dancers seem to have the most balls...

SpinDr.
Still looking for a girl who's easily... ...led.
User avatar
spindr
Senior Member
Posts: 1617
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2003 12:41 am

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Advanced lead/follow

Report a concern about this post

Post by spindr »

Originally posted by DavidB
I prefer not to have a completely 'neutral' point when leading. I always aim to have at least some compression or leverage in the lead, even when I am not actively leading a move. My lead then becomes a combination of increasing & decreasing this connection, or switching it from compression to leverage and back again.


You're absolutely right, I was just trying to capture the idea of changing the tension within the "single" step, as it were.

However my approach also has its drawbacks. Many ladies will take any leverage or compression as a lead, and will assume you are just leading another step badly. You also have to slightly change the timing of the move immediately prior to this 'invitation' lead, to make it more obvious what you are trying to do.

David
I think this is why I find this easier on travelling moves, as I can "stretch" the timing of the travel (which also gives the follower more time to realise something strange has happened to the lead). And yes, it's not many ladies who will pick up on it, but then I haven't really "seen" it taught -- I've picked up on it from dancing with Jules.

SpinDr.
Still looking for a girl who's easily... ...led.
Post Reply