Originally posted by Gus
Why is sum total of musical interpretation seemingly restricted to talking about breaks.
Er, it isn't - even in this short thread.
Breaks are NOT musical interpretation ... as said before they are simply "Simon says Stop" Watch a dance floor and watch every Herbert freeze in their tracks ... WHERE THE H*LL IS THE INTERPRETATION???.
Cobblers. Hitting the breaks just with a stop may not be advanced interpretation, but ODA mode or not, it seems pretty arrogant to me to suggest that it isn't about interpretation at all.
Surely you're not suggesting that respecting the breaks by learning to hear them coming, arranging to be in a suitable place in a move, and stopping on the break is no more interpretive than dancing blindly through them as if they weren't there at all?
Listen to Amir or the like talk on the subject. It comes back to what dance is about, using your body to paint a picture that works with the music .... in the slower passages using more gentle movements, less pace, more circles etc. ... for the more vibrant parts, using speed, space ... creating dramatic stops without stopping by footwork, expressive arms and expressive looks ....
All true, but if this had been rammed down my throat like this 18 months ago when I was on the point of giving up completely because I was so desperate for something more than moves in my dancing, I probably would have done.
At that time, I could no more have jumped to the moon than done all that.
It was, in fact, Amir, who taught a basic musicality class that I went to - and the first half of it consisted of playing a track with a completely regular and predictable break every 16 beats or so, getting people to freestyle and just stop on each break - wherever they were in the move they were dancing at the time.
Basic, doubtless; unimaginative, probably... but for people like me, obviously a mere amoeba in comparison with such as yourself, it was a hugely helpful way of starting to learn how to listen and
make a start on dancing more musically. And I think I've improved a little since then.
ODA or not, I think encouraging people to take their first tentative steps into the world of dancing musically is much better than making the whole of it seem completely inaccessible.
Still, there's nothing quite like giving someone a good kicking just when they're thinking of getting themselves up...
Chris