Originally posted by DavidB
If all you do are 'flashy', or 'interesting' or 'special' moves (whatever you want to call them) then it quickly loses any interest to the spectator. The whole dance certainly does not become 'interesting' or 'special'. And after 30 seconds or so, the individual moves cease to be special, or even noticable.
A dance needs contrast. It needs complexity, and also simplicity. It needs speed, but also slowness. It needs power, but also finesse.
The best dancers in Ballroom, Lindy, WCS, Cabaret, ballet, jazz etc all have this contrast. Many of those considered the best in Modern Jive do not, and you can really see the difference. Every top teacher (in these other styles) I've listened to, whether in private lessons, or workshops, TV interviews, magazine articles, or just chatting, has talked about this 'light and shade' at some point.
All of which is true and also totally avoids the point, unless I didn't make it clearly enough.
I'll use Trampy as an example (as he's managed to get himself at the very beginning of the Jivemasters video so easy to ref) - there's plenty of light and shade, plenty of contrast, speed and slowness, power and finesse and also closeness amd open space. But you are hard pressed to find an ordinary return or even a beginner's move that he hasn't made special or interesting(not necessarily flashy, which is not the same). Eg he started with a slow deliberate 'return' which would be quite boring were it not a contrast to what follows. In the second, faster record, there's maybe three 'basic' returns at a push. What he
didn't do is stand there doing a basic return after every move.
I'd have to trawl through severl hours of Cambers double sets probably to find DavdB, so he can claim to be boring if he wants - James (who I hadn't watched before JM) is around the middle I think so will have to check. I barely need to look to see if Miss Haslam padded her winning entry with boring moves or standard (ie as taught in a beginner's class) returns as a way of creating contrast lol - hardly! - ooops - she does promote her video a lot, but didn't stop to do it on this occasion.
On a making returns special, this was a short list someone else came up with the last time I discussed it: "you can jump thru a return at several time markers, you can crouch, you can kneel, you can alter your spin and/or the angle of your head as you spin, you can scoop you spare foot along the floor."
Even cerocshops try to give variations on the 16 basic seroc moves. But look at any freestyle (eg Blackpool clips) and what do you see: millions of octopuses, millions of returns, etc. People learn how to make them nice but teachers rarely point out that they can make all moves nice
all the time (and
still have lots of contrast.)
If the top teachers who have disagreed with me so far really think that you should keep boring filler moves then I think you are practicing 'do as I say, not do as I do'.
There are many regular teachers, on the other hand, that sincerely believe that if you do a basket or first move you have
got to include a bog standard return straight afterwards as a matter of principle (and that it's not jive if you don't) - and it's their message that is getting through to the majority of intermediates, who carry on doing them rather than dancing like Trampy or DavidB (or probably James - have only seen you dance once so far mate - sorry - I doubt if you do include boring fillers though, especially as you won the Ceroc champs in London didn't you?)